Brandonb

There's more to it than this. I'm pretty sure I know what it is... and I like it!!! Can't wait to read the post if it happens!

OK, now that ^ was just a plain nonsense post. <_<

Are you comparing me and you? Why are you asking me? Right now I don't trust you at all.

Well, I think I got this figured out. Does anyone else?

I never said anything about that they would target me more. I meant what I said, that by going with it I may be less likely to die by them than the rest of the innocents. Edit: You read into my statement way too much. Innocents always try to lynch me no matter what I say, and baddies always target me too! I'm playing this game for self-preservation. Apparently even this action will be my demise! <_<

I thought I had explained myself clearly early in the game. The GR is a rival to the mafia, they would probably want the innocents to kill it for them. As I have stated before, I figured that they probably do know who the GR is b/c otherwise they would probably use the yakuza as a bargaining chip instead. That's about it

Wow, I feel like a total Newbie for not getting that! Kinda like a "Grand Newbie" So yeah, you're right, there's noway CL could have been the LP. Thank you for putting that so delicately

I'm just curious, but does ANYONE have any clue what CL was? Phaze do you realize that she may have been the LP? Which means the GR wins tonight if a doc/healer doesn't protect you!

OMG, this is nuts! I do have a few theories, but I don't wanna give the baddies any ideas, so I'll share them after the night post (if I live that long).

Woooooooooooooooow! I missed alot. Let me catch up and I'll get back to everyone! Hopefull with a few theories!

Yeah, apparently no one is looking at this the same way I am. I agree with you, he's been kinda suspicious. Though I really don't care to wait for his defense. I'll withdraw my vote from him if something changes. Host: Unreality 1) GC 2) Frozen - voting for LIS 3) Frost - voting for GC 4) Brandonb - voting for LIS 5) Dawh - voting for LIS 6) Ysan 7) LIS 8) Clueless 9) Twoaday 10) Cherry Lane - DEAD [?] Killed by Mafia 11) Johnson 12) Puzzlegirl - voting for LIS 13) Phaze - voting for Brandonb 14) Mekal - voting for voting for tolecnal 15) Rene 16) CrazyPainter - voting for LM 17) Pw0nzd - voting for LIS 18) Dusty - voting for LIS 19) LM 20) Dnae 21) Tolecnal ~And with that, BB went to bed

He lives in India, he' probably sleeping right now.

Me too! But it really does seem to be as much of a win/win as we can get right now.

I am not a QA, or any kind of baddie for that matter, but you are right, I sure do have stuff to gain out of this. Apparently you haven't read my previous posts (nor the previous rosters) so you don't understand my reasoning that we can dispense a lesser innocent in order to save a potentially critical innocent from lynching, PLUS get the GR out of the game. Why are you against this? It sounds to me like you must OBVIOUSLY be the GR or a scared Yakuza. Plus I hopefully have another thing to gain out of this, which is that if I am trying to get this done, then the Mafia will be much less likely to target me. Use your head and read the posts.

damn man, can you PLEASE use the current ROSTER!?

Oooh I hadn't thought of that, good point. Not to mention that we have the Vagabond, who will hopefully knock out at least one of the QAs for us. Edit: You're still using an old roster Rene. I withdrew my vote.

That wasn't Frozen, it was me. And if you read my previous posts you will see my reasoning behind it. Also, you're using an old roster, you should update it.

mmmmmm, good point. I dunno what to do about that though. If we are promised baddie identities, and they follow through. I can't figure that we could do better than a baddie lynch every day, can you? I think I'm going call it a night. I will be back to vote in the morning. How much time is left UR?

I had withdrawn mine for now if you hadn't noticed.

Hehe, I'm not a lawyer, yet I got a few more years ahead of me. Yeah, I think that's pretty obvious. My thoughts are that the Spy and the Inspector are not gonna come out this early, they don't have enough information to do that. Instead of accidentally lynching one of them, or the Defender, or the Vagabond, or saving role, we can cross our fingers and lynch a less critical innocent. The Bomb can't lie detect "I am innocent" statements anymore, so I don't know why the mafia wants to take them out so bad. But it sounds like a good trade to me IF they are going to keep up their end of the deal. Even if they don't keep their end of the deal, it's not a terrible casualty to take. The bomb can't help us like it used to, it's much less of an innocent defender, and slightly more of a baddie aggressor. So I know this is going to make me look like a baddie (everything I do always does), but I am going to vote for Tolecnal. I believe it is in our best interest until we find more information in the following posts. If no one is with me, I am more than happy to change my vote if someone knows something that I don't. Host: Unreality 1) GC 2) Frozen 3) Frost - voting for GC 4) Brandonb - 5) Dawh - voting for LIS 6) Ysan 7) LIS 8) Clueless 9) Twoaday 10) Cherry Lane - DEAD [?] Killed by Mafia 11) Johnson 12) Puzzlegirl 13) Phaze 14) Mekal 15) Rene 16) CrazyPainter - voting for LM 17) Pw0nzd 18) Dusty - voting for LIS 19) LM 20) Dnae 21) Tolecnal Edit:Update Roster Edit 2: Well apparently the train has begun to move in a different direction, so I will withdraw my vote for now.

Yeah, that was a really easy and almost cheap win for the Jihadist. I think the same type thing may be happening with the Yakuza. I thought it said in the rules somewhere that they have their own secret objective. Edit: BTW, how much time is left? And is anyone else considering voting for the bomber?

Ur right. Like I said, it's making a deal with the devil, or devil(s). I just don't know what to do. Assuming they keep their word then the game goes on at a good pace. With only about 7 people dead from baddie night killings by the 4th night. But if we don't do what they say then we are pretty much guaranteed to lose 9-10 people at the hands of the baddies by the 4th night b/c they will organize the QAs. But then AGAIN, if the don't stick to their word then we are out the 9-10, PLUS the SB.

This was the first part of the post: "[strangely enough, we figured out who the GR is on the first night! Amazing huh? We’re not bluffing! So here’s the deal. If you all Lynch the SB for us today (Tolecnal) then tomorrow night we will give you the Reaper’s identity. Think about it, if you wanted to you could let him/her live through the day so the Ninja can have His/Her epic battle that night! That’s what we would like to see. You can be sure of the GR's identity, when we give you the name tonight and you lynch him/her tomorrow. This deal that we are offering Sounds like a bargain to us! Heck, we may even throw in a Yakuza!" I initially thought that the Mafia were full of it, but after reading this, then rereading the rules "The Mafia know who the members of their rival gang, the Yakuza, are (but not who is Oyabun and who is Shatei)" and what Unreality said, I'm thinking otherwise. If the Mafia know who the Yakuza are, then why not just offer a Yakuza instead of the GR? If it wasn't for this I would think that they were full of it about knowing the GR. So, is it worth it to make a deal with the devil in order to take out the most elusive baddie in the game?

To tell you the truth, after the last few games, I am terrified to say anything. Especially with the thoughts I have about the situation. All that's gonna happen is that people are gonna see my suspicious looking avatar and try to lynch me again. Plus I have info that I drew from the post which no one else has noticed, but I don't wanna share it, b/c then I'll be accused for that too! I think I'll wait for someone else to get the ball rolling this time.

Yes, much better Thank you