Brandonb

**RULE QUOTE** "they [the surviving QAs after the Illusionist dies] are immediately notified and a secondary mission is given: lynch a specific person the next day (the person is chosen randomly by me and is not a QA)" I had Sinistral pegged as the Illusionist. So now we are in trouble... we must lynch a person that is not the objective of the last QA. And the only one among us that is FOR SURE not on the list, is the QA him/herself. IF THE INSPECTOR KNOWS THE IDENTITY OF THE LAST QA, PLEASE COME FORWARD!!!!!!! Otherwise... I have another plan.......

I'm in

But I wasn't about PW. It came down to a choice b/w PW and Frozen. I Picked PW b/c I would not have cared if I killed'em (doesn't contribute much at all). hehe

Frozen

Well, it's a good idea to pursue that also, it may yield results. We're both talking about Chad right?

I think the answer is simple... The QA. The QA's job right now (Though it seems that they may not even realize it) is to kill the GR, so that the Illusionist Evolves into the Yeti. So, since the QA is hunting the GR, it would make sense that.. since the GR couldn't lynch you (b/c you came out) AND didn't push to lynch the defender (as I had hoped s/he would) then the GR should be going after the one hunting him/her at night. Because pretty much everyone thought that LIS was a QA, then the GR was probably voting for the QA. Of course we can't be sure, but that would surely have been the best move. There is, of course, another possibility. Though I am not going to discuss it. B/C the strategy may not have come up yet in the minds of the baddies...

The only "Facts" are the roles that say "DEAD" next to them in the roster, that also have their role listed next to them. There's gonna need to be at least some rudimentary logic to draw more than those.

Well, I'm a Mafia baddie at heart. No matter what clothes I wear Helps me get into their heads.

Well crap. Sorry I'm still not helping much! <_< *-PW is an innocent-* Grrrr, I wanna kill sometime! (Thank Frost I didn't tonight!!! )

hehe, I called him being Mafia Then again, I did say he could be Penguin

sure 1) Unreality - DEAD - [spy] 2) Brandonb - voting for LIS 3) Frozen - voting for LIS 4) Slick - voting for Frozen 5) TwoaDay - voting for LIS 6) Yoruichi-san - voting for Sinistral 7) Mekal - Sinistral 8) Itachi - DEAD [?] Killed by Ninja 9) CrazyPainter - voting for LIS 10) Cherry Lane - voting for Sinistral 11) LIS - voting for Sinistral 12) Nayana - DEAD - [Doctor] 13) Dawh - voting for LIS 14) pw0nzd - voting for LIS 15) GC - DEAD [?] Killed by Mafia 16) Dusty - voting for LIS 17) Puzzlegirl - DEAD - [Quarky] 18) Tolecnal - voting for Sinistral 19) Rene83 - DEAD - [Mafia] 20) Sinistral - voting for LIS

So.... I'm trying to figure out who to pick for tonight. I'm thinking PW. B/C PW hasn't been very active, which would make me feel no regret for killing him (If I got to use that ability) no matter what his role is. ANY THOUGHTS?

Ur prob right, there's been too much posting this game for me to even start to bother analyzing everything like I used to. But those are my guesses from what he has said and done.

Well, LIS is either the Penguin or the last Mafioso. I guess we're gonna see which it is! Edit: then again he could also be a QA, but I'll stick with the previous two mentions

That's interesting... Since LIS pretty much claimed that role already. I wonder which one of you is lying!?

Mekal was taliesin... EDIT: Wait, nvm, wrong thing

OH!!!!!!!! OH!!!!!!!!!!!! IDEA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Since the Healer more than likely saved the defender last night... Then the defender is vulnerable tonight no matter what. So we should lynch DUSTY!!! As a masked lover, lynching him will take out the other mafioso!! (Unless Itachi was the other masked lover, which I don't believe he was). Dusty may die tonight anyway, so at least this way we get a baddie! WHO'S WITH ME!?

U know... if the Inspector has the name of a LIVING Mafioso, AND the name of a LIVING QA... It may be a good time to out urself. We can take out the Mafioso in the lynching. It's possibly the last mafioso, so there's no super kill move tonight. Anyone have any thoughts on this? I'm thinking that the Inspector should not come out unless s/he has at least TWO living identities. Edit: 1300 posts! 13 more to go before it looks like 13 13= B B hehe

Here's the thing though... We are not going to lynch the people listed above. We know better than that now. I think the best move bay just be for the Penguin to reserve the ability for now... (Can't it be used any day on or AFTER day 3? not sure...) The odds of the penguin helping a baddie is really high right now. Just a suggestion... Plus, as you said Y-s. I'm not an important role right now, so the baddies aren't gonna take me out at night, and I'm not getting lynched during the day. So the Penguin definitely... at the least... needs to pick someone other than me, if they are going to.

Ok, here's the "UNCONFIRMED" roster LIS. (People either confirmed in the night post, or people who are still alive and have claimed innocent roles and have some sort of reinforcement). The (-) symbol means they are dead, and bold means confirmed by Frost. -1) Unreality - [spy] 2) Brandonb - [Janitor] (My Claim / No Reinforcement) 3) Frozen - 4) Slick - [innocent] (I say I spied him) 5) TwoaDay - [bomb] (UR says he spied him) 6) Yoruichi-san - [Ninja] (Backed up by Dusty) 7) Taliesin - -8) Itachi - [?] (Logic says Baddie) 9) CrazyPainter - [innocent] (UR says he Spied her) 10) Cherry Lane - 11) Dnae - -12) Nayana - [Doctor] 13) Dawh - 14) pw0nzd - -15) GC - [?] (Logic says Quarky) 16) Dusty - [Defender] (His claim / No reinforcement) -17) Puzzlegirl - [Quarky] 18) Tolecnal - -19) Rene83 - [Mafioso] 20) Sinistral - OK! That about sums it up!

Yeah I think you're right, I'm pretty sure the answer to both is no. As for the "last remaining QA" question. I'm pretty sure the rules in Mafia IV were that the last QA was reduced to an every-other night killing, opposite the GR killings, though I could be wrong. I dunno what the rules are now for that situation.

The Penguin doesn't get lynched. No role at all is revealed (though you would still know )

Did Mekal permanently replace Taliesin? Or is Taliesin back in the game?

hehe, good! We'll have VI completely impenetrable from loopholes! If the Inspector makes it to day 6, he turns into whatever innocent piece you want (like getting a pawn to the other end of a chess board). jk BTW, what is this about the GR getting kicked out if the Ninja is killed by someone else? Is there no back-up for the GR?

Probably doesn't matter. The inspector will not live that long anyway. The inspector is (maybe) a powerhouse by day 3, but doubtful to live beyond that b/c of the saving restrictions. Plus the inspector will not want to come out with their role early (and turn into a target). Maybe something should be done on day 6, but I doubt it's gonna happen