It's good that somebody can count around here (I sure can't, and I guess JB is only slightly better than I am).
Still, that doesn't change the correct conclusion, which is
(first) the puzzle statement is totally consistent and has a correct answer and
(second)
So, it takes a village to solve a puzzle. jb_riddler, vinays84, and CaptainEd arrive before you, riddled corpse of a puzzle in hand.
We deposit it at the feet of HellFire, whose puzzles are clearly and accurately stated, and hard.