Jump to content
BrainDen.com - Brain Teasers


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


bonanova last won the day on April 23

bonanova had the most liked content!

Community Reputation


1 Follower

About bonanova

  • Rank
    Retired Expert
  • Birthday November 3

Profile Fields

  • Gender
  • Location
  • Interests
    Choral music, performing and directing, photography.

Recent Profile Visitors

27539 profile views
  1. @EventHorizon said, But once Plato says that "one die is a 4," it doesn't merely prune out the ones without 4's. That’s the crux of it. EH is correct that this reads on Monty Hall. But more directly on the long-running Teanchy-Beanchy post (one of his two kids is a girl, what’s the probability he has two girls.) First people said has to be 1/2. Then others (including me) said (all that matters is that) it can’t be BB so it’s 1/3. Both wrong. so I made this one up to show that the informant’s algorithm has to be known. Nicely explained.
  2. And so thought poor Aristotle until today's class. He knew the probability of two dice making seven, until his teacher told him the value of one of his dice. Then he reasoned it to be different. Ah, the magic of conditional probability, he thought. But then he reasoned further that it was not the knowledge of which value one of his dice had, for it did not matter whether that value was 1 2 3 4 5 or 6. It was seemingly only that it had a value. But what kind of conditional probability is that? Was he not already aware of that? One of his dice has a particular value. Six values engender six cases. In each particular case he reasons the probability of seven changes to a new value. Worse, there are no other cases. Therefore in every case it changes to a new value. How then could it have the value he originally imagined? So there's the question that lurks within the flavor text. Beneath the surface perhaps, but now fully revealed for all to ponder.
  3. @CaptainEd Brilliant.
  4. @flamebirde Yes. The gun’s owner did the deed. Implied but not stated. Good catch.
  5. If it takes the 10-car Silver Streak passenger train twice as long* to pass the 93-car Big Boy steam freight train going in the same direction as it does going the opposite direction, what is the ratio of their speeds? *Meaning the time during which there is any overlap of the trains.
  6. Now, what was it we were talking about? Oh yes ... wherrzzz Beeel? I'll tell you. You know why I tell you? Because Bill would want me to. But this time the old man was not talking to the impossibly gorgeous Beatrix Michelle Kiddo. It was to a guy. A guy who was on a mission to kill Bill. A guy with the name of Al, Jack, Joe or Tom. Which one? Well, it's your job to determine which. Here's what we know from police interviews that followed the discovery of Bill's cold body on a lonely stretch of country road late last night, along with the fatal gun that belonged to one of them ... the murderer. So read on and see where the evidence leads. But fair warning, exactly half of each of the suspects' four statements are lies. Al: I didn't do it. Tom did it. Sure I own a gun. Joe and I were playing poker last night when Bill was shot. Jack: I didn't do it. Al did it. Joe and I were at the movies last night when Bill was shot. Bill was shot with Joe's gun. Joe: I was asleep when Bill was shot. Al lied when he said that Tom killed Bill. Jack is the only one of us who owns a gun. Tom and Bill were pals. Tom: I've never fired a gun in my life. I don't know who did it. Joe doesn't own a gun. I never saw Bill until they showed me the body. Who was the rat who done poor Bill in?
  7. Plato: Good morning, class, today's lesson is on probability. Aristotle: Fantastic. I'm headed to Vegas this weekend, and I can use some pointers. P: Curb your enthusiasm kid, this is serious stuff. Here, roll this pair of dice, but don't look at the the result. OK, good. Now without looking, tell me the probability that you rolled a seven. If you're going to play craps this is important. By the way, I can tell you that one of your dice is a four. A: Hmm... So I could have rolled 41 42 43 44 45 46 14 24 34 54 or 64, all with equal likelihood, with 34 and 43 making seven. That's a probability of 2/11. P: You're on a roll kid, now let's do it again. Great. Again without looking, what's the probability you rolled a seven? By the way, I can tell you one of your dice is a one. A: So I could have rolled 11 12 13 14 15 16 61 51 41 31 or 21, with 16 and 61 making seven. Hmm... it's the same as before - 2/11. P: And if I had told you one of your dice was a five? A: Well ... I guess it really doesn't matter what number you tell me. It will always come out the same. The probability will be 2/11. P: So what can we deduce from that? A: That the probability of two dice making seven is ... 2/11. But wait... Hey, you're not really Professor Plato, are you? P: No. I'm an insurance salesman. So ... what exactly is the probability of making seven?
  8. Yes. The restriction is only that they can't read each others' labels.
  9. Four identical boxes, each box containing 3 balls, each ball being either black or white, were placed before four men: Al, Bert, Cal and Don. No two boxes contained the same selection of ball colors. Each box bore a label that correctly identified the contents of one and only one of the boxes, but no individual box bore its correct label. After each man, at random, was given one of the boxes, they were given the following test. Each in turn, and out of sight of the others, was to blindly remove two of the balls from his box, read the label on his box, and then endeavor to tell to the others the color of the third ball, which remained in the box. It did not seem a difficult task, but the results were a bit surprising: Al: I've drawn two black balls. I can tell you the color of the third ball. Bert: I've drawn one white ball and one black ball. I can tell you the color of the third ball. Cal: I've drawn two white balls. I'm not able to tell you the color of the third ball. Don: (who was blind, and could not read his box's label) I don't need to draw. I can tell you the colors of the balls in my box. I can tell you the color of the third ball in each of the others' boxes. And then he proceeded to do so. How did he tell?
  10. You're right. Nice solve.
  11. You can eliminate the second case else there would be another X in the puzzle statement. Nicely done.
  12. Didn’t all break ... just rules out the case that all broke ... anything else is possible Between Ed and Jim means beat one and lost to the other. I have somewhat different answer.
  • Create New...