1. Yes. We shouldn't lose an attack since we do not know who is frozen.
2. No if they HP regen. Yes if no HP regen.
Otherwise someone could go "frozen" and rest up if they are close to death.
And now Brainiac has two kills worth of gear and coins.
Cube, haven't you noticed my attacks on you have been well below the amount that you can regen?
Off the top of my head...
The Dresden Files Series - Jim Butcher
Enders Game - Orson Scott Card
The Kingkiller Chronicle - Patrick Rothfuss (Really looking forward to the third book)
--R--
ARROW = 1
ALLOW = 0
GRAPH = 0
edit - I think the +5 should be split between Thalia and I. Since she would have gotten this if THROW had been scored correctly.