Joe's Student
-
Posts
787 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Blogs
Everything posted by Joe's Student
-
Because tactically it makes sense. The SM won't be targeted by the prisoners, thats a silly move seeing as the SM can only vote now, there are more priority innocents out there. And the SM can only save from the terrorist so as the terrorist is dead the SM's role is only to vote as an innocent . If they come out, we can focus in on baddies easier, and they won't be a wasted target for the SA or Room Cleaner or us at the next lynching...
-
Unreality: your point (2) has given me something to think about, and I'll not just stop considering things now that I've voted. BUT I'm still gonna stick with my first thoughts and vote, but happy, with more evidence (in favour of your innocence, or against someone else), to be convinced to vote for someone else. As for me, I have nothing to defend myself against . I made a vote, tried to draw a response from someone I believed to be Akatsuki, and have backed up my vote with (in my eyes) a valid reason. Whether other people agree with where I'm coming from, we'll see . So I don't see any suspicious behaviour there
-
Unreality: That's a fairly large answer for a first day vote . So ok you asked me why i just made a sweeping statement? Simple: to see your reaction . Not sure what to make of it yet.. As for why I'm voting for you is actually more to do with a post made by CP: Post. Ok so this would be a strange statement for an innocent. "Plus you don't even know who your team mates are" is an odd complaint for an innocent. If CP/(unreality) was indeed an innocent why would she complain about not knowing her team mates? Sure that's the way it's been in any Mafia-type game from the start. Baddies have BTSC, innocents are in the dark. But this time Akatsuki only partially know each other. Which is strange for baddies and which is why i think CP made this statement. Because she/(unreality) is Akatsuki. So yea I stand by that, it's all there is to go on so in all honesty, I'm as sure as I can be at this stage that you're a threat to our precious Konoha... As for Kat, well you were the most staunch supporter of giving Itachi the time to find a replacement for her, and not vote her dead. So this along with one other thing makes me think she's your partner Akatsuki. And before you try and goad me into saying the one other thing, I'm not going to say, and I have no obligation to do so
-
Good point Kat. So our wonderful stage magician could you come forward please? You won't be targeted by the prisoners tonight because your role doesn't effect the prisoners AND there are more important innocent rules that threaten the prisoners out there... So if you can come forward... go ahead please, would help us alot
-
Well my vote is going to be for unreality... sorry man. After reading for a while I believe you to be Akatsuki. Like everyone else I have little to go on but there's two things I've picked up on... one of them points to you being a dangerous threat to Konoha. Hokage: Tsunade 1) Puzzlegirl - voting for unreality 2) Mekal - Voting for Kat 3) Dawh - voting for Laharl 4) Prof. Templeton - voting for Kat 5) Kat 6) Prince Marth 7) Laharl 8) unreality 9) Joe's Student - voting for unreality 10) woon 11) Panther 12) Cherry Lane - voting for Kat 13) GC - voting for Mekal 14) Brandonb - voting for Kat 15) FIF - voting for Mekal 16) Wally West 17) Sinistral The other... well that makes our returning friend look suspicious. Edit: Fixing vote
-
Go ahead play, alot of these votes are only because there was a vacancy
-
I think i have it in 4:
-
Just wondering GC why you think Mekal thinks she's a baddie? I'd say I'm like most people in that there's even less to go on this time than usual so any insight on anything is welcome by me...
-
Ooo that, to be fair... sounds good. So how long after ABR4 do you think you'll start?
-
Was about to sugest that . But yeah take this as my sign up for that game if you can ... I always like trying out the evolved-from-Mafia games
-
Quick Question Itachi: Every character's chakra, or normal Attack, all have Wind, Taijitsu etc. beside them... what do they mean, what way do they apply? Thanks
-
How about we just don't take the risk as you're precious MH is dead, i.e your close enough to your win condition. So we should lynch you today, and that leaves two targets tonight for the SA. dms, PG anything to say for yourselves? You're trying to save yourselves from the SA...
-
I think everyone would play man you may wanna set it up with 40+ roles
-
Voting for GC for obvious reasons Sea God: Mekal 1)GC [Terrorist] 2)CP [Dead: killed by S.W.A.T agent] 3)JS - voting for GC 4)woon - voting for GC 5)FIF 6)Kat [Dead: Killed by terrorist] 7)dms172 8)limeliam 9)silverheart 10)PG 11)Slick - voting for GC 12)Reaymond 13)Panther - voting for GC 14)foolonthehill [Dead:killed by Prisoners][Mission Handler]
-
Guys don't listen to him! His baddie mind is corrupting us... SA RC and others i'll leave it upto you to decide but I'll just say: A baddie is a baddie is a baddie! and shouldn't be allowed to live. (Even if he is as nice as GC )
-
I'm increasingly worried your our first prisoner FOTH... RC a possible target maybe?
-
No but here's my argument ... Having played in games where a known baddie has been on the loose for a few day/night periods, i know that it causes problems for innocents. Big ones! He's already trying to interact with the pirates and more could come of that if we don't be careful (which makes me suspicious... are you a pirate <_< ?). He's already a nuisance and he will become more of a one if we don't kill him tonight. Also he's a confrimed baddie, if the SA targets someone else he could end up killing an innocent by mistake... Edit: all in Mafia spirits GC Edit 2: Yeah was thinking that about Slick too, but at the same time it's not a good idea for Prisoners to kill off another baddie, it's not in their interests so early in the game... so i trust Slick (for the time being anyway) Edit 3: Nurses be careful about protecting FOTH, remember we have a hitman in our mongst this game... and I'm worried it might be him/her... (sorry i don't know your gender )
-
That's what I mean, but only I would have to disagree and say that the SA should get GC, that way it's a sure kill, it would do us no good if our RC got Save...
-
Btw I'm not thinking I know better than anyone else what to do, y'all are the ones with your roles and I'm sure you have your own probably better ideas, it's just i thought I would try and add a bit of organisation, and counteract GC's mischievousness!
-
Hold on innocents. What if one of us discovers a new baddie during the night? Then we have 2 baddies and only one of them lynch-able. GC is going to get his kill fair enough, unless Nurses choose cleverly, but there's a habit in Mafia games of confirmed baddies being left to wreak havoc amongst innocents (Brandonb in M4F14- 7, sweetness kat in a recent ABR). Which is what will happen if GC is left alive after tonight! So i have to disagree, SWAT, he is a known baddie.. go for him. Because you could kill an innocent by accident. Ok so here's my thoughts: -SWAT: Get GC. -Nurses: Save a) Slick and someone else (i wouldn't mind a bit of protection ) -Room Cleaner: Pick FOTH, PG, or someone else you think is suspicious, hoping you get the right option. (Try not to pick who you think SLick will try and identify...) -Slick: Do your own thing man O and Stage Magician, try and make a guess based on GC's list, but bear in mind that he might be trying to trick you, and instead going for someone else completely different... just a thought. SO yeah the fact that GC is trying to interact with Pirates is a definite reason to kill him, sorry no question. As an innocent its a real problem when an outed baddie does such things, and if we leave him alive after tonight, he will continue to cause us problems and headaches... No offence GC
-
You might find this topic interesting... Multidimensional Beings
-
Based on your idea, (and maybe this is your idea )... was just thinking of a new role in any Mafia-type game; - The Riddler: Can choose one player every night to be subjected to a riddle of the Host's choosing. If they fail the riddle their night actions are indeed cancelled (because they're baffled Itachi [ok this is a complete rip off from your idea lol]), but if they get it right they have a 1/4 chance in finding out the riddler's identity...
-
Fixing colours... Sea God: Mekal 1)GC - voting for woon 2)CP [Dead: killed by Swat Agent] 3)JS - voting for silverheart 4)woon - voting for slick 5)FIF 6)Kat - voting for GC 7)dms172 8)limeliam 9)silverheart 10)PG - voting for Reaymond 11)Slick-voting for GC 12)Reaymond-voting for GC 13)Panther - voting for JS 14)foolonthehill If you want to add a vote: Click Reply to the latest vote > add your vote using a new or same colour > remove the quote tags. Thanks
-
It's almost a toss up to who you would believe (presuming GC will defend himself ). If Slick is the MinorThief, isn't it a bit risky for him to come out like that? Especially so early. People were already suspicious of GC voting the way he did, so if Slick was the MT and found something incriminating on GC then surely it would have been better for his safety, to use his GC's voting first to cast suspicion on him. Instead Slick has hinted to having a certain role, early on, which the more i think about it, isn't what I would do as an innocent in his situation. Just a thought on my part, want to wait until i hear from GC, and tbh i probably am leaning towards trusting Slick. *Waits patiently on GC to ascend to the top deck...*
-
*Off topic* Love your new avatar PG, it's a bit of a shock to the system . *On topic* Yea i agree with the comment by reaymond was iffy but I still think silverheart... just a little feeling i have.