DudleyDude
-
Posts
1827 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
7
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Blogs
Everything posted by DudleyDude
-
[spoiler=Heya MrsP ]potential?
-
-
-
Good game everyone. I'm not sure I could have won even under the best conditions but I think I should have called out tpax during D1 and voted for abhisk. At first, I was really hoping the vote would go against CP since I could have RID'ed abhisk if he survived. By the time I realized that the vote wasn't going to go against CP, I thought it was too late to change my vote w/o looking even more suspicious. I agree that I was much less a threat at D2 than the 2 remaining baddies but I think people misread my role and thought I could save myself from a lynch. I don't think anyone was looking at the numbers and taking into account the baddies vote switching ability.
-
-
-
-
Damn, Wilson. Great solve.
-
OK, doesn't look like I'm going to sway anyone's vote. I'll call no-contest. Good game everyone.
-
Way to throw out some really bad logic while at the same time putting words in my mouth. I never said Magic was a goodie, just that Magic isn't a baddie. Both remaining baddies acted last night and Magic was blocked. I think this post pretty much confirms that Medji is the other baddie. /back to work
-
hmmm, work is busy so I won't have to time to write a long defense. I will say that this is a rather obvious bandwagon and I don't really understand it. @JarZe - how in the world did I "insist" on lynching CP?? I thought it was obvious that either CP or abhisk was a baddie and I voted blindly for CP. I stated as much on my vote and I don't remember posting any further to try to sway voting one way or another. I checked in occasionally and saw that the vote would be for either CP or abhisk and I was happy either way. I guess I could have switched my vote at the last moment and joined the abhisk bandwagon, but I'm pretty sure that would have been pretty suspicious as well. @CP - What have I done to make you suspicious? I really don't understand Slick's statements during the first vote (metagaming alert: But I rarely understand Slick's statements) but I don't think you're a baddie simply based on his voting. Also based on the voting, I don't really suspect GM of being a baddie. And based on N1 and N2 posts, I've sort of cleared Magic and JarZe as well. So I think that Medji and tpax are the remaining 2 baddies. Even though I think I know who the baddies are, I'm much less confident of the ID of Baal. Other than the dead players (and I'm not even positive about Saya), I think Baal could be anyone (Except JayZe, I'm fairly certain that he is a goodie). I do know that Baal is the only player who has an RID ability. And I know I was spied on last night. So if I was Baal, I'd expect a stronger condemnation from someone and yet that hasn't happened. I don't want to out Etna, but I'm hoping that someone will come to my defense and we can try to lynch an actual baddie today.
-
-
1. JarZe 2. Abhisk – DEAD (Lynched and found to be Maderas) 3. tpaxatb - voting for Slick 4. Crazypainter – DEAD (Lynched and found to be Laharl) 5. GMaster479 - voting for Slick 6. Framm 18 – DEAD (Killed by Mid-Boss) 7. P4P - Mid-Boss (WINCON failed) 8. Slick 9. sayalzah - DEAD (Killed by the Baddies) 10. Medji 11. DudleyDude - voting for tpaxatb 12. Magic I'm voting earlier than I'd like but I have a feeling that today will be a busy one at work and I might not be able to participate much until this evening. I agree that Slick's "vision" of Magic was strange but if I remember right, he was also voting for abhisk in the end which doesn't much make sense. By the same token, GM also had a final vote for abhisk. So on my spreadsheet, that leaves tpax and medji as the most likely remaining 2 baddies. I could be wrong about the GM/Slick voting from yesterday and I don't have time to go back and reread the whole vote but I don't think it makes too much sense for any of the baddies to switch to abhisk at the end if it wasn't necessary. Anyway, my vote is on tpax (just a coin flip between tpax and medji. I don't think I have any reason to suspect one more than the other.)
-
-
-
-
1. JarZe - voting for abhisk 2. abhisk - voting forMagic 3. tpaxatb - voting for CP 4. crazypainter voting for Magic 5. GMaster479 - voting for Medji 6. Framm 18 – DEAD (Killed by Mid-Boss) 7. P4P- voting for 8. Slick-voting for Magic 9. sayalzah- voting for P4P 10. Medji 11. DudleyDude - voting for CP 12. Magic Sorry for not voting earlier, work was unexpectedly busy. My vote is just a coin flip between CP and abhisk. But I'm also perplexed by Magic's lack of defense.
-
Ah, that makes much more sense and works better with the title as well.
-
-
-
-
What happens with a tie lynch?
-
1. JarZe 2. abhisk 3. tpaxatb 4. crazypainter 5. GMaster479 6. Framm 18 7. P4P 8. Slick 9. sayalzah 10. Medji 11. DudleyDude 12.
-
I don't think that's true. There were 10 players left at that point so you should have needed 4 votes to trigger the dance condition and I don't think there was ever more than 3. I agree with tpax that that was the lynch that turned the game. Having 2 people trapped and 2 people not vote really hurt us.
-