Jump to content
BrainDen.com - Brain Teasers

Ye Olde Mafia


Guest
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 410
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

In response to Kat: Okay, either that's true, or you're lying, and your teammates are Nick, ST, and Voltage, SG being good. Either is likely, but I think ST may have been bad. SG's online, I'd like to hear things. :D

Haha, well I do have the experience, that's for sure, but unfortunately that isn't the case now. And who I'D really like to hear from is FIF. If he can prove himself, it might just clear Someguy, or it'll doom both of them *in my books at least* :3

<(^-^)>

Edit: Be back in a couple of minutes...I need some cake to help me think...

Edited by Kathleen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Understood. My best guestimation is that Impervious is the Chaos Magician, that would explain why, when he was watched, he wasn't doing anything. And I think Voltage was the Recruit, which is why, when put in a trance the first night, there were still the normal actions. Like I said, they are just guestimations. I feel VERY confident that I know who the goodies are, I just can't figure out who the exile is.

Edit: disregard the top half of this post, I think I may have missed a whole MESS of possibilties lol, but I am still certain about the last sentence.

Edited by RPGBully
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmm.. So counting the Exile as a goodie for now.. It'd be me, Randro, Liam, RPG, and Kat. ..That's five. Or Nick could be good, meaning either RPG or Kat (probably Kat?) is lying. Bah I'm so confused..

Back, with cake! *I feel like "L", sitting with cake, trying to figure out who the baddies are*

Ok, I really have NO idea if Nick is good or bad, to be honest. After what you said, I'm leaning towards bad because I trust Bully :3 Oh, and who exactly are on your goodie list Bully?

<(^-^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back, with cake! *I feel like "L", sitting with cake, trying to figure out who the baddies are*

Ok, I really have NO idea if Nick is good or bad, to be honest. After what you said, I'm leaning towards bad because I trust Bully :3 Oh, and who exactly are on your goodie list Bully?

<(^-^)>

Dude, why do you come off as such a baddie? :dry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, "to be honest" so far it is me, Izzy, Randro, and Lme. If you want the truth, you still haven't sold me yet, although, I will give you credit, atleast your'e still in here defending yourself. Funny part is, I am so lost, I don't know how ya'll keep up with it all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dude, why do you come off as such a baddie? :dry:

*Sigh* Because of games and games of being the uniformed minority...

But that's not the point. I can assure you I am good, and royally important as well :3 The Sage can vouche for me, seeing as they checked me out...Except, Sage? Don't go outing yourself, you're pretty important, and with this RID killer, we really do have to watch what we say.

Edit:

Well, "to be honest" so far it is me, Izzy, Randro, and Lme. If you want the truth, you still haven't sold me yet, although, I will give you credit, atleast your'e still in here defending yourself. Funny part is, I am so lost, I don't know how ya'll keep up with it all.

Well yeah, we're pretty sure about those three, if not positive. Of course I'm defending myself; this is a crucial vote *an EARLY crucial vote too...very unusual* And don't worry about it, it's just experience. You'll gain it eventually :3

<(^-^)>

Edited by Kathleen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

*Sigh* Because of games and games of being the uniformed minority...

But that's not the point. I can assure you I am good, and royally important as well :3 The Sage can vouche for me, seeing as they checked me out...Except, Sage? Don't go outing yourself, you're pretty important, and with this RID killer, we really do have to watch what we say.

<(^-^)>

...S**t.. I'm so unsure.. But I suppose if you were the Chaos Mage, you wouldn't know what role the sage saw you as? The sage could be dead though..

1. star_tiger - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

2. Impervious

3. SomeGuy

4. crazypainter - DEAD (Killed by the Recruit)

5. randro

6. limeliam

7. JarZe - DEAD (Killed defending Izzy from Rogue and Exile) Town Guard

8. RPGBully - Voltage

9. voltage

10. Kat -voting for FIF

11. Joe's Student - DEAD (Killed by the Exile)

12. FIF

13. andromeda - DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

14. Izzy - voting for FIF

15. IDNE - DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

16. twin_bro - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Dark Knight)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotta tell you Kat, you seem more and more suspicious to me. Royally important huh? How I wish I could look you in the eyes when you say that :ph34r: I find it interesting that you say the sage can vouch for you, then, naturally, tell them not to do so because it would out them. I am not holding out much hope for you at this point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotta tell you Kat, you seem more and more suspicious to me. Royally important huh? How I wish I could look you in the eyes when you say that :ph34r: I find it interesting that you say the sage can vouch for you, then, naturally, tell them not to do so because it would out them. I am not holding out much hope for you at this point.

Well I have to admit, there isn't much I can say. I'm not going to force the Sage out to vouche for me, that would be worse than just me being lynched; we'd lose two of us, and the game would naturally go to the baddies. So if it comes down to it, I'd rather the Sage stay hidden. I'm important, but not enough to endanger the game o.O

<(^-^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotta tell you Kat, you seem more and more suspicious to me. Royally important huh? How I wish I could look you in the eyes when you say that :ph34r: I find it interesting that you say the sage can vouch for you, then, naturally, tell them not to do so because it would out them. I am not holding out much hope for you at this point.

She's saying so because if the Sage out's themselves they can be RID'd by the baddies. However I noticed that the Sage didn't act last night (possibly andromeda?) So it'd be easy for her to say a dead person can vouch for her when dead men/women tell no tales.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

She's saying so because if the Sage out's themselves they can be RID'd by the baddies. However I noticed that the Sage didn't act last night (possibly andromeda?) So it'd be easy for her to say a dead person can vouch for her when dead men/women tell no tales.

I dunno, just because they didn't act doesn't mean they're dead...but you're probably right *sigh* But they weren't going to be much of an alibi. So what do say to the suspicion around you, Impervious? Why don't you think about that before you start pointing fingers at me?

<(^-^)>

Edit: added the more pessimistic point

Edited by Kathleen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I just came to another conclusion. Someguy is a goodie. The rogue robbed him last night, and he can't steal from his own team. He can't be the exile as the Rogue and Exile both attempted to kill the same person. So that completes the list of 5, for me atleast. Bully, Izzy, Randro, Lime, and SG. The only possibility in my mind is that Lime voted for TB because he knew it only tied the vote and thought that no one would be lynched. That seems highly improbable to me, but possible. Everyone else, by default, would be a baddie. I doubt it will do much good, but based on that I will agree to vote for any of the remaining players that we choose, just so long as we all vote together.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I just came to another conclusion. Someguy is a goodie. The rogue robbed him last night, and he can't steal from his own team. He can't be the exile as the Rogue and Exile both attempted to kill the same person. So that completes the list of 5, for me atleast. Bully, Izzy, Randro, Lime, and SG. The only possibility in my mind is that Lime voted for TB because he knew it only tied the vote and thought that no one would be lynched. That seems highly improbable to me, but possible. Everyone else, by default, would be a baddie. I doubt it will do much good, but based on that I will agree to vote for any of the remaining players that we choose, just so long as we all vote together.

Well then something is wrong :blink: I'm a goodie, so someone in that group has to be bad...we know Izzy is good, we're pretty sure Lime and Randro are good, you just proved SG...what does that say about yourself?

<(^-^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I just came to another conclusion. Someguy is a goodie. The rogue robbed him last night, and he can't steal from his own team. He can't be the exile as the Rogue and Exile both attempted to kill the same person. So that completes the list of 5, for me atleast. Bully, Izzy, Randro, Lime, and SG. The only possibility in my mind is that Lime voted for TB because he knew it only tied the vote and thought that no one would be lynched. That seems highly improbable to me, but possible. Everyone else, by default, would be a baddie. I doubt it will do much good, but based on that I will agree to vote for any of the remaining players that we choose, just so long as we all vote together.

Bully, two people can target the same player. Nothing in the Op states that the rogues nullifies the player it copies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bully, two people can target the same player. Nothing in the Op states that the rogues nullifies the player it copies.

Foxdung, I missed that when I read through...I assumed the rogue nullified when they stole *ie, if you steal something, the person no longer has it for that night* So in that case, I'm still looking at SomeGuy

<(^-^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. star_tiger - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

2. Impervious

3. SomeGuy

4. crazypainter - DEAD (Killed by the Recruit)

5. randro

6. limeliam

7. JarZe - DEAD (Killed defending Izzy from Rogue and Exile) Town Guard

8. RPGBully - Voltage

9. voltage

10. Kat -voting for FIF

11. Joe's Student - DEAD (Killed by the Exile)

12. FIF

13. andromeda - DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

14. Izzy - voting for Kat

15. IDNE - DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

16. twin_bro - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Dark Knight)

Edited by Izzy
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you are right, it will come down to your word against mine I think, which really is probably bad for me, since I am so new here. However, what it does it say for you as well. You say you know your good, I say I know I'm good, but I have been the one pointing out HOW others are good or bad in my opinion, and helping the goodie team figure out who to/not to vote for. The only thing you have said is, "I am a goodie, if you don't believe me, just ask the sage, except you can't". Hmmm? Yup, I am certain you are a baddie now. However, @#$$ your good!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only thing you have said is, "I am a goodie, if you don't believe me, just ask the sage, except you can't". Hmmm? Yup, I am certain you are a baddie now. However, @#$$ your good!

...What? *Pokes previous page* Did you see those? I've been analyzing, same as you :huh: You can't just go claiming all I've been doing is claiming a goodie! xD

<(^-^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So you are telling me that if the Rogue steals from someone, they BOTH have the same powers? I did not realize that, however, all it does is mean that SG is either a goodie or the exile, by Izzy's standards, and I agree with them btw, he is still not who I am looking to identify.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...