Brainiac100

It was more of a "Do you think anyone would play it if I hosted it?" kind of question

I would definitely play a math one!!!! If it's okay, can I start planning out a Newbie Greek Mythology Mafia?

Stake

... Snore

Stoke

The way I looked at it, there was no loop, so your action blocked his. If he had blocked you and you had blocked him, his block would have overpowered yours. So in the case you presented, vcvcvc12's role only allowed him to know who Flamebirde targeted, so vcvc didn't learn any roles through this. (I believe I said that "Flamebirde targeted no one") An action will go through if it isn't blocked.

Shake

Shame

Yes.

I didn't even think about having the save act against everything involving the NK I think the save was out of the OOP because the NK was blocking.

Host comments: About players: I was incredibly impressed by how well everyone did in this game, especially considering the fact that this was the first mafia for many of you. My only comment towards you as a whole is to pay more attention to actions in the night posts and role hints throughout the game so you can more easily deduce who each person's role is. My commendation goes to Kikacat123, who was so easily able to figure out who had what role (or she was just really good at guessing). About Mentors: The mentors during this game, Plasmid (for Kikacat123) and araver (for vcvcvc12), were absolutely incredible. They were willing to answer questions and did so in ways that made everything crystal clear. I would not have been able to answer their questions as adeptly as they did. About Hosts: I have a lot for this section... 1. Auramyna and I realized immediately after Night 1 that we wanted to change the rule from "NKs have a carrier and are blockable/redirectable" to "NKs do not have a carrier and are not blockable/redirectable." The reason I did not mention it in Day 1 was because I did not want to mess with lynch because everyone would (correctly) assume that Flamebirde was the Chorus. In hindsight, however, I realize that I should have shared this information as soon as we decided it so as not to give the Baddies an advantage. 2. I personally do not think we should have given the Baddies a block, since the NK was already blocking. Instead, they should have had a spy. 2a. The NK should not have been blocking, either. On N1, akaslickster saved himself, but because the NK was blocking, he died. As the whole point of a save is to save a person from the NK, he should not have died. 3. Numbers 1 and 2 made the Baddies entirely too strong. They were able to interfere with a large majority of the actions each night, even getting to the point on the final night where only the Baddies and Indy were the only ones who successfully acted. 4. A few errors were made by me throughout the game: 4a. I should have mentioned earlier that the rule about the NK not having a carrier had changed. 4b. Araver said this in a PM: Question to hosts: Original post states: "Day 2 onwards - all in tie roll randomly". When I read this, I first understood that each in the tie roll have an independent chance of being lynched. D3 post shows: "Finally, the majority of the people decided it was either dyalDragon or Nana. [...] Tails. Nana77 was suddenly swept up by the students and ejected from the school". The Day post suggests a different rule set: the one where exactly ONE in the tie will be lynched. Was this the intent of the rule from the OP? This caused me to have an error in the post for D3, which could have ended up changing the game. Anyways, game is a learning experience for everyone. If anyone has any comments/criticism for me, please share it with me. I would be more than happy to know how I can improve If you did not enjoy this game, do not fret! There are many different types of mafia out in the world of the interweb, so please do not be discouraged if you feel as though you did not like this or you weren't good at it. Thanks, Brainiac100

Sharp

Shirk

Day 4: As the students filed into the gymnasium, only three groups remained: Chorus, Debate Club, and Photography Club. Each of the three immediately began throwing accusations at each other, all claiming not to be Chorus. dyalDragon, head of the Photography Club, shouted to lahiem, "It has to be flamebirde!! Get him!" lahiem, the ever-questioning Debate Club, disregarded dyalDragon's frantic shouting and charged towards dyalDragon with flamebirde right beside him. However, lahiem realized too late that he was targeting the wrong person, and Photography Club was taken out of the Club Fair on a stretcher. Flamebirde, the mastermind of the Chorus, knew that he could easily handle the lahiem that night and win as the last club standing with FFA. BADDIES AND INDY WIN!!!!! Roster and host comments will be up tomorrow

Day is over. Post coming up shortly!

Principals: Auramyna & Brainiac100 1. flamebirde - voting for dyalDragon 6. dyalDragon - vote flamebirde 11. lahiem - voting for dyalDragon Dead: 7. akaslickster- Incapacitated N1 by Chorus 8. marksmanjay- Expelled D1 as Prom Committee 10. Yodell - Handicapped N2 by Guitar Club 5. TheCube - Humiliated D2 as Band 9. Panther - Bullied N2 by Guitar Club 2. nana77 - Defenestrated D3 as Guitar Club 4. vcvcvc12 - scared off N4 by Chorus 3. Kikacat123 - won and left school N4 as Future Farmers of America

3 1/2 hours left!

I'd be willing to cohost the greek mythology one as a Newbie Mafia with someone much more experienced than myself

Night 4: The Chorus was in a panic on this night. They had lost another ally of theirs earlier in the day, and they realized that they were the only Musical Group remaining. Unfortunately for vcvcvc12, he was seen by the Chorus partying because one of his enemies had been eliminated. While no one but the Chorus knows exactly how, vcvcvc12 was found months after this night riding a train, eating out of a can of ravioli and babbling about how the Chorus was chasing him and he needed to keep running. The Chorus tried to instill the same fear into dyalDragon; however, this only kept dyalDragon from working towards his club's hopeful victory that night. Kikacat, leader of the Future Farmers of America, realized that during the progression of the week, the misnomer of the FFA being the"redneck club" had spread rapidly throughout the school. Kikacat caught lahiem, leader of the Debate Club, asking everyone about whether or not they were aware that the FFA only accepted 'hicks.' Kikacat hacked into lahiem's social media page and changed the password, so lahiem would not be able to post any more 'incorrect' comments until the next morning, when lahiem would figure out the password. Kikacat decided that she had caused enough damage to the school to teach them a lesson about spreading rumors. She decided to leave the school for the rest of the week to begin sewing her garden, and was shocked to find herself at the end of the week tying with the other first place club(s) in the race to get the largest group. Principals: Auramyna & Brainiac100 1. flamebirde 6. dyalDragon 11. lahiem Dead: 7. akaslickster- Incapacitated N1 by Chorus 8. marksmanjay- Expelled D1 as Prom Committee 10. Yodell - Handicapped N2 by Guitar Club 5. TheCube - Humiliated D2 as Band 9. Panther - Bullied N2 by Guitar Club 2. nana77 - Defenestrated D3 as Guitar Club 4. vcvcvc12 - scared off N4 by Chorus 3. Kikacat123 - won and left school N4 as Future Farmers of America Day 4 ends 8PM EST on Monday, April 22nd!

Hmm. Good point.

Unless... Are proper nouns allowed? If so, Livy (He was a Roman historian)

Tidy

Principals: Auramyna & Brainiac100 1. Flamebirde 3. Kikacat123 4. vcvcvc12 6. dyalDragon 11. lahiem Dead: 7. akaslickster- Incapacitated N1 by Chorus 8. marksmanjay- Expelled D1 as Prom Committee 10. Yodell - Handicapped N2 by Guitar Club 5. TheCube - Humiliated D2 as Band 9. Panther - Bullied N2 by Guitar Club 2. nana77 - Defenestrated D3 as Guitar Club Night 3 ends at 8PM EST on Sunday, April 21st!

Day 3: The students stood around the gymnasium, throwing around accusations about who had eliminated Panther from the Club Fair the previous night. Finally, the majority of the people decided it was either dyalDragon or Nana. The students, being asinine teenagers, decided that a coin toss was the fairest way to determine which person had headed the group who had gotten rid of the poor guy. The masses asked Nana "Heads or tails?" "Heads," Nana called out confidently. Janitor Brainiac100, who happened to be walking by, dropped her purse, out of which a quarter fell. It began rolling... rolling... rolling...

Actual time.