If you read the post after that, you'll notice that I just remembered that there was an unidentified error in the night 2 post. I believe the error was that Anon was Trelawney meaning Trelawney shouldn't have acted. I think Shadow should have fixed that as he would have been essentially outed whether she got it right the first time or not. As for your accusation, you have no basis for the "must". "Lying." Interesting accusation coming from the only person I have reason to believe is a baddie. (Which isn't really saying much since there's only 3 of us).