Recently a self-proclaimed stand-up logician held a show with thirty people. here is his opening dialogue:
Hello folks. It's an honor to be on Amateur Logician Night, here on the Internet. How many of you are from out-of-town? Let's see a show of hands.
Now, the people who raised their hands may be truth-tellers who are from out-of-town, or you may be liars who are from in-town. As the amateur logician, it is my job to determine who is really from out-of-town, and who is not. This is not an easy job, as you can well imagine.
If I were to ask how many of you are truth-tellers, then all of you would raise your hands. The liars would have to lie, and claim to be truth-tellers.
Now, let's see a show of hands, all of the people who raised your hands the first time, when I asked how many of you were from out-of-town. Very good. All of you, who now have your hands up, are from out-of-town.
Some of you are truth-tellers who raised your hands both times. You are from out-of-town. Some of you are liars who did not raise your hands last time. You too are from out-of-town. So, all of you who now have your hands up, are from out-of-town.
Thank you. Thank you. What a crowd. Thank you.
Would this approach work in identifying those that always lie and those that always tell the truth? Why or why not?