DudleyDude

harmony

Another really nice one PG. I enjoyed it quite a bit.

Good morning MrsP.

Host: Principal G 1. Mrs. P - poisoned by the Trojan Spy - found to be the QB 2. Clozo! 3. akaslickster-voting for Clozo 4. Riranor - clawed by the Tiger and found to be the Gamma Nerd 5. Marth2 6. crazypainter - fell into the underworld and found to be the Defensive Linemen 7. DudleyDude - voting for tpaxatb 8. Marth - compassed by the Nerds 9. DarthNoob - Knocked out senseless by super fist by the Nerds 10. tpaxatb 11. Derrai 12. scsw - robot choked by the Nerds INDIE: WIN Can't say I'll miss DN from this game since I'm pretty sure he was neither baddie nor goodie. I never trusted he wouldn't side with the baddies if given a chance. @akaslickster - your instinct has been pretty good so far this game but I haven't seen or heard enough from Clozo to have an opinion yet. I'm pretty certain you're another goodie and also pretty certain about Marth2. Of the remaining, I think tpaxatb has been the "quirkiest" so far so I'm going to start my vote with him. But I'll be watching to see what Clozo has to say as well. Maybe random.org was right about him from the beginning. And like you, I'm more than willing to change my vote depending on today's posts. We really need to make sure we get one of the baddies with this lynch.

salty night occur

This one was fun. And I wouldn't worry too much about hard-vs-easy, everyone is enjoying yours so you're obviously doing something right

I can't promise to be around much over the next few days so I'll pass the turn to whomever has a good word.

draw

Finally, we got one. And if I've got the logic right, this pretty much guarantees that Marth2 is a goodie now as well, right?

dram

I was just assuming the "fish in a barrel" bit was a post from the nerds. I guess GM might have put it in on his own, but my first reaction was that it was from the nerds. But since no one else has commented on it, I could be mistaken.

Apparently, I'm taking my wife to dinner tonight so I might not make it back before the lynch (And yes, I tried to explain to her that day cycles were more important than night cycles but I couldn't sway her vote.) I hope we are right this time with the choice and good luck with the vote. I'll try to make it back before the day cycle is over but I'm not optimistic.

Yep, it's going to be the biggest and bestest riddle ever and all the other riddles that disagree are just jealous

I think I'm torn at the moment. I don't have any real reason to doubt the accusation but that would probably be true for more than half the players. The more I reread DN's recent posts, the more they confuse me. I do think there is a really good chance he's the Trojan and I'm not sure if he's siding with the goodies or the baddies or just trying to make sure someone other than him gets hung. You've thrown out some weird accusations yourself but that might be based on an actual strategy that I just don't understand yet (I still can't think of why someone would bother to check the boards anonymously while they are also logged in.) Riranor, Clozo and Derrai have been so quiet that I have no real idea which side they are on. I'm not convinced that Marth2 is necessarily a good guy. Am I the only one who noticed that there didn't appear to be a fake news post on N1 but there was on N2? I think I understand why we didn't want to have our Bully kill on N1 because of the bad odds but is there a good reason they wouldn't post something on N1? And tpaxatb posts a lot but doesn't really say very much. You posted the first vote of the day and made it against Riranor simply saying you "had suspicions". Marth2 is the only one who presented an actual argument and it seemed to be completely based on D1 voting when we were all voting completely blind. Anyway, I'll leave my vote for now but I'd really like to hear actual arguments or reasons as to why people are being accused. I'm not sure if I'd be better off voting for someone w/o really knowing whether they are goodie/baddie or voting for someone I am pretty sure is the Trojan.

aye, I'll ask for a hint as well. I keep looking and looking and can't decide which one is the cryptic, let alone how to solve it.

Another good one MrsP

not this but this (mostly).

not quite. Are we still working on the original answer?? or is that it... I think we can still work on the original. Gub's guess was good, but pretty different than what I had intended.