Ye Olde Mafia II

[Guest]

Wow just have to say that I am surprised at the amount of info going around...many players hinting at their role.

If you are who you say you are, you all painted nice targets on your back. And IF you are who you are hinting at,

you are a role I would rather not lose. So shhhhh. You should only be hinting if your head is on the chopping block.

Otherwise I cant help getting a bit suspicious.

I hinted so that baddie status is verified. The baddies already know exactly what I know, *AND* about whom I know it.

My thinking is that if we vote out Saya and it turns out they are innocent then we Know Woon is a baddie. What

so you all think?

1. GMaster479 - DEAD (Killed by the Undead Knight)

2. Pablos4pandas - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

3. JarZe - voting for Sayalzah

4. SG – DEAD (Killed by the Dark Magician)

5. Crazypainter voting for Sayalzah

6. blackcat1313 - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Town Guard)

7. woon - voting for Sayalzah

8. Sayalzah

9. tpaxatb - voting for Sayalzah

10. Medji - Voting for Sayalzah

11. DudleyDude - Voting for Slick

12. Izzy – DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

13. akaslickster- Voting for LIS

14. Framm- Voting for LIS

15. Lost in Space (LIS) - Voting for Slick

I really disagree with this. But...on the other hand we'll be in trouble.

Right now, there must be a baddie currently voting for sayalazah, unless we are being played.

I am worried about being down 5 to 4 if we are being played. Especially since I have a feeling the target of the rogue this night, and what the rogue would do with that.

[Guest]

I really disagree with this. But...on the other hand we'll be in trouble.

Right now, there must be a baddie currently voting for sayalazah, unless we are being played.

I am worried about being down 5 to 4 if we are being played. Especially since I have a feeling the target of the rogue this night, and what the rogue would do with that.

I absolutely agree with you, at least one baddie is just "following along" to make himself look like a goodie. I hope woon is right, after all he's the one pushing to get Sayalzah lynched; although, now that I think about it, someone could be trying to save a "more important" baddie from the lynch... Interesting....

I think the day should end any minute now, so we just hope the KC makes the right decision tonight. So KC be careful on who you target tonight.

[Guest]

As you know I'm not normally quiet, but here Netherlands, we just had the equivalent of your thanks giving (sinterklaas)I held back to see were this push on me was going, fortunately there are two spies and one should have the right info.

****Using a friends ipod.. Can someone put my vote on Sayalzah please.****

[Guest]

1. GMaster479 - DEAD (Killed by the Undead Knight)

2. Pablos4pandas - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

3. JarZe - voting for Sayalzah

4. SG – DEAD (Killed by the Dark Magician)

5. Crazypainter voting for Sayalzah

6. blackcat1313 - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Town Guard)

7. woon - voting for Sayalzah

8. Sayalzah

9. tpaxatb - voting for Sayalzah

10. Medji - Voting for Sayalzah

11. DudleyDude - Voting for Slick

12. Izzy – DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

13. akaslickster- Voting for LIS

14. Framm- Voting for LIS

15. Lost in Space (LIS) - Voting for Sayalzah

Updated including LIS vote.

[Guest]

There's no use defending myself. I'll be dead anyway.

Why is it that I've been lynched in every single Mafia I've ever played? Too many gruesome deaths.

1. GMaster479 - DEAD (Killed by the Undead Knight)

2. Pablos4pandas - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

3. JarZe - voting for Sayalzah

4. SG – DEAD (Killed by the Dark Magician)

5. Crazypainter voting for Sayalzah

6. blackcat1313 - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Town Guard)

7. woon - voting for Sayalzah

8. Sayalzah- voting for woon

9. tpaxatb - voting for Sayalzah

10. Medji - Voting for Sayalzah

11. DudleyDude - Voting for Slick

12. Izzy – DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

13. akaslickster- Voting for LIS

14. Framm- Voting for LIS

15. Lost in Space (LIS) - Voting for Sayalzah

[Guest]

Are we just waiting for PM to come online?

[Guest]

There's no use defending myself. I'll be dead anyway.

Why is it that I've been lynched in every single Mafia I've ever played? Too many gruesome deaths.

No effort to defend yourself? So my deduction is correct!

[Guest]

I just ran through a bunch of stuff in my head. And just realized we're in super trouble.

I think the baddies will try to kill twice tonight. And I think I know who the target of at least one of the kills will be...and probably the other target as well.

I THINK I've given enough hints to the Bard that s/he knows who to target to prevent one of the kills.

I HOPE I've given enough hints to the Cleric that s/he can figure out who to try to target. The cleric can either guess to try to save the target of one of the kills, or have a 50/50 shot at getting the Undead Knight. I'm hoping that the cleric can see why one of the baddies shouldn't be targetted, and can figure out the other two from which to choose. I'm not sure what the best thing to do is though.

Yes, even though that is projecting a strategy, I think it's the right move. Anything to prevent two goodie night kills. Even if that means that the rogue uses the bard to block the KC instead of stealing the KC, I'll be all right with that outcome. Otherwise we'll be in a worst case 4 goodie 3 baddie situation...with not much night options.

[Guest]

I'm never taking another class in Newport News EVER again...A 30 minute drive in the morning taking an hour and a half in the afternoon is not right... Going to work on day post.

[Guest]

Day 2: Not so stealthy

As the day began after the 2 newest deaths, the voting started against LIS and Slick but no one was certain of either. The first to speak up with certainty was woon.

“Salayzah is a baddie. I know it. We must lynch him now!”

However, no one really listened and the debate continued between Slick and LIS.

The tie between the 2 seemed to continue throughout the day.

The prince and his men came into the crowd however to end the debate as they grabbed Slick. “Come with us, you are to be taken in under orders of the Prince.” Slick offered no resistance as this was one way he could get out of this.

Just before slick was taken, people were starting to distrust Salayzah and were beginning to add votes, however, before their minds could be changed, the King called the day early. At the time of the call LIS had the most votes and was going to be the one to be lynched.

Once LIS heard the call and knew he was in the lead, he tried to duck away and escape with his stealthy skills. However, he was easily seen by many and they grabbed him before he could get away. Just as he was grabbed and shaken up a bit, money and other valuables began to fall from within his clothes. Many of the villagers glared at LIS and grabbed their lost belongings that the Rogue had taken from them.

LIS had been found out and he knew they weren’t going to let him go now. The villagers tied up his arms and legs and erected the gallows. They stood LIS up on the trap door as they pulled the noose around his neck. LIS looked to his comrades, but they seemed to show no remorse for him. They weren’t about to reveal themselves for just one member. LIS was about to say something, probably an attempt to get out of this but he was unable to as the trap door was released below him, his body fell and his neck snapped from the sudden stop the noose caused.

The villagers cheered at getting rid of one of the baddies but knew it wasn’t over yet. They dispersed to plan for the nights actions.

1. GMaster479 - DEAD (Killed by the Undead Knight)

2. Pablos4pandas - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

3. JarZe

4. SG – DEAD (Killed by the Dark Magician)

5. Crazypainter

6. blackcat1313 - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Town Guard)

7. woon

8. Sayalzah

9. tpaxatb

10. Medji

11. DudleyDude

12. Izzy – DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

13.akaslickster {Captured by the Prince}

14. Framm

15. Lost in Space (LIS) - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Rogue)

[Guest]

YES! I knew I was onto something. I am glad my change of vote didnt mess us up. Next lynch it will be that same ... Salayza.

Traffic is a pain. I live in Los Angeles so I know which way the traffic flows. Its how you stay alive and sane.

[Guest]

Looks like the king was on to something. I say good call ending early.

[Guest]

Ok, 1 of the baddies gone, sure they will plan something great tonight. Hopefully cleric still alive and save the right players.

[Guest]

I was just informed of a grave mistake. HOLD ALL ACTIONS AND POSTS UNTIL I HAVE FIXED IT! Thank you!

[Guest]

Day 2 Addendum: Dark Magic Attack!

Marth was overseeing the game, his interest growing more and more. As he stared down from above watching the game, he heard his accuracy assistant begin to act rather unusual and burst from his seat and run over.

“Master Marth, there’s a problem...You must see this,” the assistant handed Marth a paper.

Marth looked it over and his eyes grew in shock. “A tie you say...How’d I miss that?”

“When the King ended the day, there was a 4-3 vote LIS-Saya...One of the votes for LIS was from Slick, so when he was captured by the prince, his vote was negated causing a 3-3 tie LIS and Saya...”

“Hmmm...Yes...I see...That King is a crafty one...I’ll give him that...”

The villagers could hear the entire conversation as they looked to the sky at the Game Master. Sayalzah was already on the run. But it was too late for him...There was no where he could hide that the Game Master wouldn’t find him.

A bolt of “white lightning” shot across the sky and struck Sayalzah, causing him to drop his book of secret arts as he fell. The Dark Magician, was no more.

1. GMaster479 - DEAD (Killed by the Undead Knight)

2. Pablos4pandas - DEAD (Killed by the Knight Captain)

3. JarZe

4. SG – DEAD (Killed by the Dark Magician)

5. Crazypainter

6. blackcat1313 - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Town Guard)

7. woon

8. Sayalzah - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Dark Magician)

9. tpaxatb

10. Medji

11. DudleyDude

12. Izzy – DEAD (Killed by the Rogue)

13.akaslickster {Captured by the Prince}

14. Framm

15. Lost in Space (LIS) - DEAD (Lynched and found to be the Rogue)

Sorry that I didn't see that before. I guess when I rush, I don't notice things. 2 in one shot...I think that's a first. Nice job. Well, night 3 begins now. Get those actions in.

Also...Can anyone catch the references made in this post

[Guest]

WOOT! GO KING/PRINCE!

[Guest]

Holy... crap...

[akaslickster]

Holy... crap...

Success at last!!!

[Guest]

Marth:

Which one was considered to be killed first? IOW: Whose powers did the recruit take?

PS (I thought I was going to be gone today but my road trip for work was cancelled so I'm here after all)

[Guest]

Technically since they both died at the same time (I just didn't notice at first), he could choose which power to take.

[Guest]

OK...

Based on that, y'all know what to do (and good job prince/king )

[Guest]

HA!!! I was right! On both calls! Yeah King/Prince!!! Great job!

edit:

I am stuck here seeing a mistake I made on my spreadsheet. And it kinda messes up my other theories.

Anyone feel comfortable discussing who they think is who?

Edited December 8, 2009 by crazypainter

[Guest]

Success at last!!!

=)

[Guest]

HA!!! I was right! On both calls! Yeah King/Prince!!! Great job!

edit:

I am stuck here seeing a mistake I made on my spreadsheet. And it kinda messes up my other theories.

Anyone feel comfortable discussing who they think is who?

My entire spreadsheet has been filled out since the middle of day 2. I don't see any reason to discuss, really. The only real question has to do with which of the two was the recruit, and what role he decided to take on.

If the recruit took on the dark magician, then he can only be killed by the cleric at night.

If the recruit took on the rogue, then he can copy but can only be killed by the KC at night.

The way I see the night playing out. I'm assuming that the two baddies left have been identified by everyone (obvious who they are). It's going to really depend on who the recruit took over. I'm putting all the hints in, even though some options might not possible due to slick's imprisonment (yes, I know who you ALL are...with the exception of which baddie is which...oh and which of SG and Izzy were the exile...)

The cleric can either opt to save one of us (probably him/herself) OR take a 25% shot of hitting the recruit (50% shot that the recruit took the dark mage * 50% shot of hitting the recruit).

The bard should block one of the two baddies to try to prevent the kill. 50/50 shot of guessing right here.

The KC should just go after one of the two baddies. Again, there's a 25% shot of failure depending on who the recruit took over.

Obviously the sage should check out one of the baddies, to determine which is which for the lynch. I think the sage should go after the first baddie in the list...

Because I think the Tower Guard should check out the second baddie in the list...this will keep the targets spread out.

Now, there are some other scenarios played out depending on whether the recruit chose the rogue...because the steal would be in play.

Overall odds, I think we have about a 25% shot of a baddie going down, a 25% shot of a goodie going down, and a 50% shot of the night ending in status quo. It's going to depend on what the cleric decides to do, who the bard decides to block and what the recruit decides to take over (that's probably the biggest key).

[Guest]

Edit: there is one very specific scenario dealing with the recruit taking over the rogue, but I'm not going to delve into that one until after the game is over...