Hirkala

Glyc, target Gmaster as the PK!!! I'm pretty sure it's him!!!

I think you are the other baddie here, Gmaster. Night 2... Mabel redirected Filly to check you out. Right after, Isabelle tried to spy you. If you were Isabelle, where did Filly go after that? If he was the PK, there should have been a post saying that the PK was trying to figure you out. But, the PK has no action that night. It's too coincidental that Filly was redirected to you and Isabelle then spied you. And I don't believe in coincidence. EDIT: Foolish comment...

Last letter must be S… BOMBS got 1, CAMEO got 0 = Not M for 3 BOMBS & BATHS got 1 each, BIRCH got 0 = Not B for 1 BOMBS, DARTS, BATHS each got 1, the only consistent letter is S in the 5 spot… Don’t know if that’s enough for it, but that’s what I have so far.

I knew this was going to happen... Stupid baddies and your voting for other baddies to confuse us... LOL MM can say she is Edith all she wants, but then says I am bad. WHY WOULD EDITH HAVE SAVED ME LAST NIGHT IF I WERE BAD??? Think about it. As for the 3rd baddie, well, that can wait.

Make it quick! Day ends at 3:30 EST, right?

Exactly. Glyc can RID kill the last baddie after RUTH/MM is lynched! Although, it's still possible that both baddies are voting for you now, Glyc... Hopefully, Gmaster gets on soon and says something.

BATHS

Changing Glyc's vote for him. 1)-Yuiop-DEAD-Killed by the Pirates. 2)-Filly - Voting for Glycerine 3)-LJ -DEAD-LYNCHED-Samuel 4)-Harvey - DEAD-LYNCHED-Frederic 5)-Glycerine - Voting for Molly Mae 6)-Hirkala - Voting for Molly Mae 7)-Slick - DEAD - Killed by Ruth. 8)-Molly Mae - voting for Glycerine 9)-GMaster - voting for Hirkala 10)-Framm - DEAD - Killed by Pirates. Oh, man... I just reread everything and really paid attention to the details this time. Molly just kinda screwed herself over... I KNOW Glyc is good. And everyone else here should as well. Molly voting for Glyc wasn't very wise. Just kinda sold yourself out by calling Glyc out as being bad and voting for him. It's kinda obvious that you are bad, as I said. And with Filly changing his vote to Glyc... Means he is either bad, didn't pay attention to the posts, or had a brief lapse in judgment... Either way, the goodies need to vote MM. She is bad for sure. Once she is gone, we can figure out who the other baddie is...

1)-Yuiop-DEAD-Killed by the Pirates. 2)-Filly - Voting for Glycerine 3)-LJ -DEAD-LYNCHED-Samuel 4)-Harvey - DEAD-LYNCHED-Frederic 5)-Glycerine - Voting for Filly 6)-Hirkala - Voting for Molly Mae 7)-Slick - DEAD - Killed by Ruth. 8)-Molly Mae - voting for Glycerine 9)-GMaster - voting for Hirkala 10)-Framm - DEAD - Killed by Pirates. YAY!!! I saved myself!!! Good timing, too... I figured they were going to come after me, so I, as Edith, sent an action warning myself. Good thing I did it quick, too. If they had gotten theirs in, I would have been screwed. I'm about 99.9% positive that MM is Ruth. I'm still unsure about the 2nd baddie, but we goodies NEED to vote for MM. Only baddie confirmed right now. VOTE MM!!!

I think they will try to take out MG Stanly. He can take one out tonight and then tomorrow, we can vote the last one out. We wouldn't have to lose anyone else.

Well, this just opened up a whole new can of worms... 4 people voted for LJ, which means at least 1 baddie voted for him. Glyc, I still think you are good, but that would mean that 2 baddies voted for one of their own. If you are bad, then Gmaster would likely be good. Or you and LJ and Gmaster are bad and decided to not only let one of you die, but risked the vote switching to another of you. You could have done it to alleviate suspicion from all of you. If not, then 2 baddies let LJ fall to keep themselves hidden. This game is going to give me an aneurysm... LOL

WOOT!

I still am... His defense was flimsy and him "outing" himself at the last minute... Why didn't he talk at all before this?

Hey, if he was good, I had just as much hand in us losing as you...

What is going on? So confused...

1)-Yuiop-DEAD-Killed by the Pirates. 2)-Filly - Voting for LJ 3)-LJ - Voting for Hirkala 4)-Harvey - DEAD-LYNCHED-Frederic 5)-Glycerine - Voting for LJ 6)-Hirkala - Voting for LJ 7)-Slick - DEAD - Killed by Ruth. 8)-Molly Mae - Voting for LJ 9)-GMaster - voting for LJ 10)-Framm - DEAD - Killed by Pirates. There I am... Sorry, so late... Long night at work last night...

Yeah, but what action did he take after?

Don't know what else I can say without giving away my role... And it would be better for the goodies if that stays quiet... Uuuuhhh, I PROMISE I'm good???

With this order of action, maybe LJ is the Pirate King... He sacrifices himself to bust Slick out, Ruth kills Slick, freeing the PK. With this order, they could have timed it to make that happen like that. I'm gonna assume it wasn't random chance that Slick got wiped out RIGHT after he was freed. Makes LJ bad. As for the other two baddies... I have some theories, but I will wait a little longer on those...

That can't be... LJ was taken to prison... Then, when Slick died he was freed...

OH!!! So, LJ breaking Slick out of prison wasn't an Isabelle move! It was just Ruth's way of killing him off... Had to be out before she could kill him... Hmmm...

I'm with you on that Glyc... Doesn't line up with Filly being Isabelle. Which makes me think he may be bad. LJ really needs to say something about it, though...

WHOA!!! I NEVER said anything about voting for Harvey!!! In fact, I said that Harvey was LESS suspicious! And I didn't vote for him! I was breaking down the 'Let's kill off the prisoners to out the Sergeant' deal. MM, Harvey and LJ were all going after Slick while he was in jail and I said it was suspicious that they would try to kill off prisoners to out the sergeant. That would be a good tactic for the baddies to rid themselves of the indy and maybe kill off a goodie or two. Then, they would win. I said MM and one of the other two might be bad and I was more suspicious of LJ than Harvey. People made their choices on their own. I had nothing to do with them lynching Harvey.

Why would I call out one of my own if I were bad? If I were bad, I would sit around and wait for the goodies to implode on ourselves, which we have been doing a good job of lately... Yeah, MM pegged Filly or me on being Isabelle, but since Filly is Isabelle, I MUST be bad, right? Or could it be the fact that I am another of the goodies? Just because MM says that if I'm not Isabelle I am bad doesn't make it true. I am not bad. I am the goodie that may be able to save us all...

Unless you are mistaken about my role... The best baddies strategy is to keep quiet, but a better strategy would be to talk a lot since everyone knows that baddies are always the quiet ones. Only reason I have been quiet is because it's my first game. I am learning. But I like to sit back and watch to get a read on people. Then I can make a more educated guess. Which I have. I think it's LJ, Glyc, & Gmaster.