Since the night post basically outted me I'm not sure how I can still be on anyone's baddy list.
With that said here is what I know:
MM or GM is good (possibly both)
Hirk or Filly is bad (possibly both).
So based on that I have a higher chance of lynching a baddie if I vote for hirk or filly than MM or GM.
If Edith is still alive it's hirk and therefore filly was lying about being isabelle. However if edith isn't alive hirk is a baddie. That doesn't however clear Filly.
I know for a fact that Filly or Hirk is the Pirate King. With that said I'm voting for filly today unless I can be convinced Filly is a goodie. The surprise at the RID being right and freeing MM makes me think that MM is ruth and faked the action on herself. I'll need some SERIOUS convincing to think that Filly is anything other than the PK and that MM is anything other than Ruth.
I actually think it is more likely that Filly is lying and that hirk is Edith. I need to reread the posts to make sure about that however. The sergeant is dead (unfakeable) so ruth's ability was to look like the sergeant unless kate is alive. If kate is alive and she did that she needs to explain why basically right now... So either Kate OR Edith is alive. Ruth either imitated Edith and Kate imitated the sergeant, or Edith is alive and ruth imitated the sergeant.