[Guest]

Should this be in games or other? I put this in games for now though, but if it needs to be moved then moderators do what you have to do

Anyway, I thought i should open this thread for discussion purposes about the recently finish game Battle of Warriors. First of all though, i would like to congratulate Woon on an exceptionally good performance in hosting the game.

Anyway i did notice a slight flaw earlier on in the game. On night 3 a natural diaster occured - this could have potentially ended the game really as if the worst came, only 3 warriors would have survived. If two 6's had been rolled, only Sir Francis, Salvador Dali and Yannick would have survived. This would mean that every night these 3 warriors would all fight each other and it would be rather boring for the remaining players as it would be the same repetition over and over again. I have posted the table below to make my point.

Warrior.............Hp

Sir Francis..........65

Zuchious..............5

Corynhoole...........12

Red Dragon...........13

Froggy................7

Loki.................29

Salvador Dali........47

Solembum.............28

Unlucky Thirteen.....20

Yannick..............65

Another thing i noticed is that many of the players still survived, and the game ended rather abruptly in my opinion. Maybe if the level cap was raised a bit, and later on in the game attacks caused more damage keeping the players on edge to see if they had survived. These are just my views though on an almost perfect first round of a new game. If any of the other players have any other ideas for the next round or want to discuss about my points then join in

Thanks Reaymond

[Guest]

Well I really enjoyed the game, but I had a problem with the whole "guess the warrior" puzzles...I don't think it's necessary to try and get everyone to guess who everyone else is, I prefered puzzles that had nothing to do with who everyone was. Thats my two cents

<(^-^)>

[Guest]

Well I really enjoyed the game, but I had a problem with the whole "guess the warrior" puzzles...I don't think it's necessary to try and get everyone to guess who everyone else is, I prefered puzzles that had nothing to do with who everyone was. Thats my two cents

<(^-^)>

yes that was another thing i picked up on. It wasn't really necessary for the warriors to remain unknown throughout the game as it wouldnt really make a difference if we knew who everyone was. It happens in Mafia for obvious reasons - but i didn't really see the point in BoW. Although it was better for me because i didn't have a clue on any of the other "logical" puzzles

[Izzy]

only Sir Francis, Salvador Dali and Yannick would have survived.

You say it like it's a bad thing.

But yeah, I agree that would have been rather boring.

I enjoyed the game overall, but it was a lot more luck than skill. Wonder if there's any way to get around that?

[Guest]

You say it like it's a bad thing.

But yeah, I agree that would have been rather boring.

I enjoyed the game overall, but it was a lot more luck than skill. Wonder if there's any way to get around that?

of course its a bad thing... I would have died I suppose you being Yannick would have liked it. Oh and congratulations on your victory. Although, if we fought to the death Zuchious would have killed you, and victory would have been mine

It would be quite hard to indroduce an element of skill into the fighting though as it is all randomly selected by Woon. Adding something extra into it would just make Woons job alot harder as a host. Thats the reason why i started this topic though - to help improve the game for round 2:)

[Izzy]

of course its a bad thing... I would have died I suppose you being Yannick would have liked it. Oh and congratulations on your victory. Although, if we fought to the death Zuchious would have killed you, and victory would have been mine

Ahaha, in your dreams.

[Guest]

Basically I found a few weaknesses in game 1

1) when reach level 5 and above, with the attack power enhanced, player evolved too fast

2) no excitement about keeping the identity secretly. Must think of something to make it more interesting, or else just forget about it.

3) not enough function the warrior can perform.

So I intend to add on like warrior can choose to attack, defense, training or performing some tasks provided.

Also, there will be 2 type of attack. Normal attack need strength, magic attack need magic skills.

Magic attack will depend which element of magic you are learning. (Blue, Red, Green, White, Black)

I will eloborate it later once I have more to say.

But so far, how does it sound now?

[Izzy]

Will everyone have normal and magic powers?

Edited November 5, 2008 by Izzy

[Guest]

Will everyone have normal and magic powers?

Normal attack skill is given at the begining. Magic Power attack is by .........(secret)