Anyone want to tell me why what I did was completely wrong?
From hints given and info I had - If everyone was telling the truth by words and actions
Vine could only be Austraila
Hirkala could only be USA
Thalia could only be England
Golf could only be Germany
Maurice could only be Russia
Molly could only be Spain
Solman could only be Israel
Marq, Framm and Shadow are unknown
From there I saw it as a matter of if/then counters.
Solman countered Molly making Solman Spain and Molly Argentina
Thalia countered Maurice making Marq Russia and Maurice a baddie
Framm dead made him likely Israel
Leaving Molly, Maurice and Shadow as baddies
Why was it wrong (rule-wise) for me to put all that out there?