[Guest]

What is the answer to this million dollar question?

A. The answer is B

B. H is false

C. I is false

D. If all of the above are false, I is true

E. Four below are true

F. The answer is not F

G. If J is not the answer, G is the answer

H. Three of the above are true

I. E is true

J. The answer has to be J

I pray I didn't screw up somewhere. Hopefully it'll be fun =P

[Guest]

G

[Guest]

I think the answer is G

[Guest]

Yep =)

[Guest]

What's your reasoning, solvers?

[Guest]

It is impossible to answer when one does not understand the question. How many are true and how many false? How do you determine the answer from all the truths.

[Guest]

A and F can't be the answer. =P

Multiple choices may be true, but there's only one answer. The answer must be true, and it must be the only one that works.

What is the answer to this million dollar question?

A. The answer is B

B. H is false

C. I is false

D. If all of the above are false, I is true

E. Four below are true

F. The answer is not F

G. If J is not the answer, G is the answer

H. Three of the above are true

I. E is true

J. The answer has to be J

I had everything made except G and J, but then things started getting too confusing, so I made myself a chart (below). I wanted to make the answer either G or J, and I had to make all he other choices not work. If you look at every choice you should see a contradiction that makes that choice not possible, or more likely the note "make G false..." which would create a contradiction.

B_______________

A true

B true

C true/false

D false

E false/true

F true

G

H false

I false/true

J

nothing needed

C_______________

B true/false

C true

D false

E false

F true

G

H false/true

I false

J

make either G and J true, or G false

D_______________

B false

C false

D true

E true

F true

G

H true

I true

J

make G true or G and J both false

E_______________

B false/true

C false

D false

E true

F true

G

H true/false

I true

J

make G false or G and J both true

G_______________

B either/false

C true/false

D false

E false/true

F true

G true

H either/true

I false/true

J false

everything works

H_______________

B false

C false/true

D false

E true/false

F true

G

H true

I true/false

J

make G false or G and J both true

I_______________

B false/true

C false

D false

E true

F true

G

H true/false

I true

J

make G false or G and J both true

J_______________

B true

C true

D false

E false

F true

G true

H false

I false

J true

works, if written "J is the answer," but doesn't if written "J has to be the answer" because G works too

Edited July 23, 2009 by DarthNoob

[Guest]

If you put it that way, then there is no answer. Even G cannot tell everything

Edited July 23, 2009 by Lord of the Nazgul

[Guest]

If you put it that way, then there is no answer. Even G cannot tell everything

I'm not sure what you mean. G is the only answer where everything works out, and there are no contradictions. There are a couple of uncertainties, but no matter which turns out to be true or false, it still works. (that is, if I did it correctly)

[Guest]

it doesnt have to be G

G-Z

[Guest]

The answer can be J.

A false

B true

C true

D true

E false (2 below are true, making this a false statement)

F true

G false

H false (4 of the above are true, making this a false statement)

I false

J true

[Guest]

that the answer is G