[Guest]

Hi! this is my first post

I've been banging my head on the wall because of this problem. And I'm sorry that I do not know the solution but that was one of the reason I found this forum as I was looking for the answer on the web.

So... the challenge is, can u break the figure below into 3 identical shapes?

(This can be done because I saw it in a book, unfortunatly with no solutions)

cya!

[Guest]

whoa, tough one. well, obviously there would need to be eight squares used to compose the shape. i'll keep working on it.

[Guest]

Are we required to divide along the lines, or can we do curves and diagonals?

[Guest]

  Frost said:

Are we required to divide along the lines, or can we do curves and diagonals?

There are no restrictions mentioned in the problem So I believe we can do whatever we want.

[Guest]

I couldn't get it anyway. I'll keep trying though. Nice puzzle mcomatic!

[Guest]

I see the top and bottom would fit into each other like puzzle pieces... I wonder if it's cheating to cut the shape in two, horizontally, with a straight line, then switch the top and bottom, thus making a rectangle... Then go from there. (?) -steve

[Guest]

are there any rules we must follow?

[Guest]

  Reveal hidden contents

yes there is a way

cut it in half vertically

and then put the left on the right.

lay shape on its side

and then move the square sticking out into the hole on the other side.

then cut into thirds.

[Guest]

  mcomatic said:

Hi! this is my first post

I've been banging my head on the wall because of this problem. And I'm sorry that I do not know the solution but that was one of the reason I found this forum as I was looking for the answer on the web.

So... the challenge is, can u break the figure below into 3 identical shapes?

(This can be done because I saw it in a book, unfortunatly with no solutions)

cya!

Go through the middle up and down, following the out line!

[Guest]

Wouldn't that be only two shapes topsykretts?

[Guest]

  mcomatic said:

Hi! this is my first post

I've been banging my head on the wall because of this problem. And I'm sorry that I do not know the solution but that was one of the reason I found this forum as I was looking for the answer on the web.

So... the challenge is, can u break the figure below into 3 identical shapes?

(This can be done because I saw it in a book, unfortunatly with no solutions)

cya!

i think i got it

go down the shape from topr to bottom on the second line over from the left and the fourth line over....those are your first two shapes...then take what you haveleft (the middle piece) and slit it down the middle long ways...slide one half up a square and it is like the other pieces...i may be wrong and im sorry i couldnt put the image in my answer to help describe it...im kinda new to this site

[Guest]

  crazypainter said:

  Reveal hidden contents

yes there is a way

cut it in half vertically

and then put the left on the right.

lay shape on its side

and then move the square sticking out into the hole on the other side.

then cut into thirds.

  Reveal hidden contents

since there are 8 blocks

in this rectangle and you cant divide 3 by eight I suggest you triple the eight to 24. Or subdivide the 8 squares into thirds. That gives you 24 which you can be divided by 3!

[Guest]

If you go left to right on the midlle line , following the outline, i think that is it!!!

  mcomatic said:

Hi! this is my first post

I've been banging my head on the wall because of this problem. And I'm sorry that I do not know the solution but that was one of the reason I found this forum as I was looking for the answer on the web.

So... the challenge is, can u break the figure below into 3 identical shapes?

(This can be done because I saw it in a book, unfortunatly with no solutions)

cya!

[Guest]

NO rules?? Hmm, simply move the outlying boxes into the obvious spots then slice it in thirds (8 squares each). Then again, I bet that IS a rule.

[Guest]

  Frost said:

Wouldn't that be only two shapes topsykretts?

Your right, you, need 2 lines form left to right!

[Guest]

You can take those 2 pieces sticking off and fill in those other concaved areas. Then split it in 3 by counting them off by 8s.

[Guest]

Great puzzle! Assuming that "cutting" the shape is cheating, im attemping to solve the puzzle following the lines. This is as close as i have come, someone care to relook this?

  Reveal hidden contents

Testx.bmp

Edited July 6, 2008 by Brain Dead

[Guest]

  Brain Dead said:

Great puzzle! Assuming that "cutting" the shape is cheating, im attemping to solve the puzzle following the lines. This is the closet i have come, someone care to relook this?

  Reveal hidden contents

Testx.bmp

Right idea. I was doing the same thing. You have Blue & green looking the same but yellow is the wrong shape. Keep trying - I think you're very close.

[Guest]

This is a tricky one. I can make FOUR identical shapes very easily and the solution for TWO is pretty obvious but THREE is escaping me. I'll keep playing with it.

[Guest]

  Reveal hidden contents

Go 3-D! Cut the shape out and wrap it around a round cylinder or square block so that the blocks that stick out fit like tabs in the "missing" area. Then divide easily. This is just a variation of the classic "thinking outside the box" puzzles.

[rookie1ja]

  thirdbase said:

  Reveal hidden contents

Go 3-D! Cut the shape out and wrap it around a round cylinder or square block so that the blocks that stick out fit like tabs in the "missing" area. Then divide easily. This is just a variation of the classic "thinking outside the box" puzzles.

sounds good ... works fine at the beginning ... however, could you post the picture completely solved (distinguishing the 3 parts with 3 colors)

[Guest]

  rookie1ja said:

sounds good ... works fine at the beginning ... however, could you post the picture completely solved (distinguishing the 3 parts with 3 colors)

Sorry but I don't know to draw it and upload it but I think I can describe it for you...

  Reveal hidden contents

imagine a paper the image on a paper towel that is just wide enough to wrap around the core. (interlocking the blocks into the "slots" when you wrap it. Then slice it into thirds - if the core was vertical, just count down every two squares and slice. That will leave you with 3 RINGS of 8 squares each.

[Guest]

  Reveal hidden contents

As I can't see the original graphic. So I took the picture from Brain Dead post.

Will it be easy to divide by following the zigzag outline? What I mean is:

Unless I got the wrong picture. With this arrangment, we can divide into even more identical shape than 3.

[Guest]

  Reveal hidden contents

Print the grid (I used powerpoint to enlarge it) Then cut it out with scissors. roll it into a cylinder (it becomes obvious which way to do it). ta da!

[rookie1ja]

  thirdbase said:

Sorry but I don't know to draw it and upload it but I think I can describe it for you...

  Reveal hidden contents

imagine a paper the image on a paper towel that is just wide enough to wrap around the core. (interlocking the blocks into the "slots" when you wrap it. Then slice it into thirds - if the core was vertical, just count down every two squares and slice. That will leave you with 3 RINGS of 8 squares each.

well done, it is so easy that way ...

  Reveal hidden contents

[Guest]

Is this problem that difficult.?

Given that there are no restrictions, it is for us to slice the shape into whatever way we want to.

  Reveal hidden contents

In this figure, the three shapes re identical. That's what the problem asks for. It may not be in the exact dimensions. But here is the key.

Cut the shape into 4/3 of a square from the outline, along the outline. You will have to draw two lines, making three identical shapes. This also holds good for identical area and shape propositions.