Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

Cruise Ship Mafia II

457 posts in this topic

Posted (edited) · Report post

But he did survive...if the nurse hadn't turned up, he might have survived anyway. He's already been brought back to like once by Mekal in water (yes, I realise that's just part of ' the story')

For what it's worth, I also believe he is probably a innocent or, rather, I think that there is more chance of him being innocent than anyone else. Lynching him on the fact that he could be the terrorist would be a big risk for us, so I think he's safe.

edit: clarity to say that the terrorist survived previously in water

PG is obviously innocent and is just messing with our heads other wise she wouldn't she talk about being a baddie if she is one, so with that lets get GC. ;) jk i think.

Edited by dms172
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

There's not much to go on, but maybe Mekal left out a hint in the night post. Back with a bang? So Kat or woon, maybe? It looks dim, but anyways a start. So I will kick it off. BTW, I wouldn't be surprised if Kat was a prisoner. She's one who is having a field day with baddie roles. But going on external info is not good, so I vote for woon. Someone has to start the bloody voting, and so I kick it off.

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by Prisoners]

3)JS

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick

12)Reaymond

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

PG is obviously innocent and is just messing with our heads other wise she wouldn't she talk about being a baddie if she is one, so with that lets get GC. ;) jk i think.

It looks like you and Panther are making an alliance yet again. Trying to kill me like you did in Mage Duel. You sound like bad boys to me now. :P

EDIT: Typo

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

It looks like you and Panther ar making an alliance yet again. Trying to kill me like you did in Mage Duel. You sound like bad boys to me now. :P

As someone also on the receiving end of their Mage Duel alliance, I think I'd be careful of dms/Panther too. I got invited to join their alliance (Frost, Cherry Lane, dms and Panther) early on so protected Frost who was running short of SP - then they all killed me!

(Sorry: that was a bit OT)

I'm not sure about voting for woon, at least until he has had a chance to defend himself...

edit: but at least we've started

Edited by foolonthehill
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

As someone also on the receiving end of their Mage Duel alliance, I think I'd be careful of dms/Panther too. I got invited to join their alliance (Frost, Cherry Lane, dms and Panther) early on so protected Frost who was running short of SP - then they all killed me!

(Sorry: that was a bit OT)

I'm not sure about voting for woon, at least until he has had a chance to defend himself...

edit: but at least we've started

Oh! I didn't know that. They killed off CL too now. And I was wondering how Frost was surviving. But that shouldn't influence this game. Hopefully! ;)

It's always a good move to start voting for someone on day-1. Then when we hear their defense, we can change our vote, if needed. I think Woon will be online in a short time.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Odds are pretty high that JS is an innocent. He also gave a hint that he might be a ship worker, so that narrows it down some. However, I'm very interested to know why GC chose Woon to vote for? Anything behind that GC??

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by Prisoners]

3)JS

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick

12)Reaymond

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

As I said the voting needed to started. And Mekal in the night post said something about "back with a bang". Of course, he could just have meant the prisoners in general, but last time Woon was a prisoner and so I voted for him. I know it's not a solid reason, but Woon can defend himself later if he's an innocent. Anyway, nobody was willing to vote, so I started the proceedings.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I thought two people were, eh.. a bit put out maybe, that i wasn't dead after last night's proceedings. One of them I'm keeping my eye on. The other well:

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by Prisoners]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick

12)Reaymond

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

erm... I don't know who to vote for now its kinda hard on the first night

how about

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by Prisoners]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick

12)Reaymond - erm.. Mekal lol?

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by Prisoners]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick

12)Reaymond - GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

maybe im just being a bit cynical, but the style of his comments seem to point somewhere for me :S

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

A prisoner voting for an innocent first, is a good cover. This vote may change as the day progresses.

CP was killed by swat agent and please keep it correct ya'll. Thank you. Use reply and erase quotes to keep the colors.

Edited by akaslickster
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Adding my vote...

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

Btw reaymond: you don't have to put it in a spoiler :P

Edited by Joe's Student
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

ye JS thought it would get a bit confusing if i put 2 lists up tho even if i did vote for the sea god on one.

Edit: slick i think you can read my mind :P i thought exactly the same thing.

Edited by reaymond
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Well, I have nothing to go off of except my female intuition and something about the way Reaymond responded to the night post made him sound not entirely sincere:

OK... that night was unexpected to say the least :P feel gutted for ya tho CP out already

Geesh, the first lynching gives me the willies (wanna guess why), so I hope I'm not jumping the gun. Sorry, Reaymond, I have to go with my gut.

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG - voting for Reaymond

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Well, I have nothing to go off of except my female intuition and something about the way Reaymond responded to the night post made him sound not entirely sincere:

Geesh, the first lynching gives me the willies (wanna guess why), so I hope I'm not jumping the gun. Sorry, Reaymond, I have to go with my gut.

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG - voting for Reaymond

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

sorry if my first post didn't really seem too plausible to you PG, but lets face how many of us expected there to be 2 killings in the first night with 1 person saved from a random choice?

edit: reworded

Edited by reaymond
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

*Off topic*

Love your new avatar PG, it's a bit of a shock to the system :P.

*On topic*

Yea i agree with the comment by reaymond was iffy but I still think silverheart... just a little feeling i have.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

*Off topic*

Love your new avatar PG, it's a bit of a shock to the system :P.

Whoah how did i miss that last time PG?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat - voting for GC

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG - voting for Reaymond

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther

14)foolonthehill

Well, usually I want to hear some evidence before I vote, but experience tells me that I should just vote and get the first day over with. We either get a baddie or we don't, lets just hope luck is with us. GC, are you innocent? :huh:

~Kat

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

sorry if my first post didn't really seem too plausible to you PG, but lets face how many of us expected there to be 2 killings in the first night with 1 person saved from a random choice?

Well, seeing as the Prisoners and the SA can kill on the first night (that makes 2) and there are as many as 4 saving roles on the first night (both nurses, stage magician and room cleaner) it wasn't all that unexptected. What was a bit surpriseing was the nurse's lucky guess to save JS.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Well, seeing as the Prisoners and the SA can kill on the first night (that makes 2) and there are as many as 4 saving roles on the first night (both nurses, stage magician and room cleaner) it wasn't all that unexptected. What was a bit surpriseing was the nurse's lucky guess to save JS.

sorry just realised i missed out a comma in my first post which put the emphasis in saving from a random guess

edit: "but lets face how many of us expected there to be 2 killings in the first night, (comma here) with 1 person saved from a random choice?"

Edited by reaymond
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Well, seeing as the Prisoners and the SA can kill on the first night (that makes 2) and there are as many as 4 saving roles on the first night (both nurses, stage magician and room cleaner) it wasn't all that unexptected. What was a bit surpriseing was the nurse's lucky guess to save JS.
I think you are guessing mainly. Oops, you got lipstick on my collar. Any how, love the av.

I have more than one reason for choosing GC, so I ask you to trust me and switch if you are definitely an innocent. I happen to know something. ;)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I think you are guessing mainly. Oops, you got lipstick on my collar. Any how, love the av.

I have more than one reason for choosing GC, so I ask you to trust me and switch if you are definitely an innocent. I happen to know something. ;)

tbh tho slick we are all guessing here as we only have responses and comments to go by :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I think you are guessing mainly. Oops, you got lipstick on my collar. Any how, love the av.

I have more than one reason for choosing GC, so I ask you to trust me and switch if you are definitely an innocent. I happen to know something. ;)

Well, I am definitely an innocent, but I can't change my vote just yet for a few reasons:

1) What if You are a baddie? Just because you're my sweetheart doesn't mean you didn't get randomly assigned a baddie role.

2) If I trust you and switch immediately then folks will think you and I are somehow in cahoots like the baddies are and I don't feel like having to justify my way out of that.

3) You're right, I am guessing. Who isn't? The only people who might know specifically who some of the other roles are is the Minor Thief, the Registry Worker and possibly the Room Cleaner...but what are the chances the get a baddie right off the bat?

I need to stick with my guns for now. I'll check back in later this evening and see how the vote is going before I change my mind.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Well, I am definitely an innocent, but I can't change my vote just yet for a few reasons:

1) What if You are a baddie? Just because you're my sweetheart doesn't mean you didn't get randomly assigned a baddie role.

2) If I trust you and switch immediately then folks will think you and I are somehow in cahoots like the baddies are and I don't feel like having to justify my way out of that.

3) You're right, I am guessing. Who isn't? The only people who might know specifically who some of the other roles are is the Minor Thief, the Registry Worker and possibly the Room Cleaner...but what are the chances the get a baddie right off the bat?

I need to stick with my guns for now. I'll check back in later this evening and see how the vote is going before I change my mind.

Not a big deal because he may be one but, we shall see soon enough. :D
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

So maybe, CP was a prisoner? I need more time to think it out. :wacko:

would someone, the one who killed me, let me know later on why they chose me??? What did I say?

so sorry to miss the cruise, at least it was fast and unexpected, good luck innocents!

I will see you in my dreams...or on another company's cruise!

Off to the land of milk and honey to drink of my sweets!

Edited by crazypainter
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Since Mekal's comment 'back with a bang' i've been thinking alon the lines of JS. Maybe?? Because I think it is too lucky that the nurse voted to save the very person that died(or should have LOL) in the FIRST NIGHT, JS might be the terrorist :unsure: . Or maybe GC :unsure:

My Vote:

Sea God: Mekal

1)GC - voting for woon

2)CP [Dead: killed by swat agent]

3)JS - voting for silverheart

4)woon

5)FIF

6)Kat - voting for GC

7)dms172

8)limeliam

9)silverheart

10)PG - voting for Reaymond

11)Slick-voting for GC

12)Reaymond-voting for GC

13)Panther - voting for JS

14)foolonthehill

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.