Jump to content
BrainDen.com - Brain Teasers
rookie1ja

Crocodile Sophism

Recommended Posts

Guest
I would think that the only way to make ANY sense of the situation is for the woman to repeat back to the croc EXACTLY what he said to HER: "If I guess right, you'll give my baby back, if I dont, you'll eat him. That's what you'll do to him." He'd have to return the baby, because she's CORRECT NO MATTER WHAT. Eh? hehehe

I totally agree. Unless if he changed his mind. You see if you said what he said he might change his mind and say that he was about to return the kid, so he would eat him. But then that would mean he never made the deal at all, if you were wrong. So it is a sort of paradox. Confusing, eh? :huh:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I agree with Mr. Brownstone. Sort of.

I'm assuming that the mother loves her child, and that she wants her baby to remain alive and intact. The statement 'you will eat him' would ultimately be correct, but fundamentally, the answer given by the mother should be one which keeps the baby alive. The crocodile, being of above-average intelligence, would want the mother to say 'you will eat him', as it knows that the mother would be too scared to say 'you will keep him alive', thinking that the crocodile would want to eat the baby. So, the crocodile would purposely think about not harming the baby, in order to harm it once the mother gets the question wrong.

Following Mr. Brownstone's theory, the answer would be right, and yet wrong at the same time. Even if the mother got the question right and the baby didn't die, the crocodile, fuelled by its hunger and animal instinct, would run over to to the mother and baby and devour them both.

In all probability though, if someone saw a talking crocodile, they'd scream 'OH MY GOD! A TALKING CROCODILE!' before pulling out a gun and shooting it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

My dear friends. You are overlooking some rather obvious facts.

First, the inclusion of the nile, the crocodile, the mother and the child is drawing cultural images relating to ancient Egypt. This symbolism can be taken as a direct reference to that place and time.

Now. In ancient Egypt the prevelent belief about the after life was that the heart of the decesed is balanced against a feather. If the heart is found to be lighter than a feather then the decesed is aloud to enter the Egyptian version of heaven and live out an eternity in joy.

We all know that a childs heart is at least as light as a feather and it can be assumed that this wise croc would know that too. So the mother simply has to say, "You will make my child very happy." The croc would then see that if he gives the child back to his mother, the child will be very happy. And if he eats the child, the childs heart will be weighed and found to be light and airy, as childrens hearts are want to be, and he will be placed in heaven where he will be very happy for all eternity. :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I disagree with the majority of you guys. If you say "you will eat my baby" then he gives you back the baby because that's what he was going to do. But then he doesn't eat the baby after all, and you must give the baby back because you were wrong. But then if he is about to eat the baby, your right and he must give it back and it goes on and on, a contineous circle. A parodox. I hope I was clear.

One last note: even if you were right, in real life the crocodile wouldn't really care. But then, in real life crocodiles don't talk. And if I were the mother, I'd just go "OMIGOD! A talking crocodile!" and shoot it.

Edited by Bunny Master12

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

She should say that he will eat her son. If she is right, she gets him back. If she's "wrong", he'll have to give him back anyway because she would still be right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
My dear friends. You are overlooking some rather obvious facts.

First, the inclusion of the nile, the crocodile, the mother and the child is drawing cultural images relating to ancient Egypt. This symbolism can be taken as a direct reference to that place and time.

Now. In ancient Egypt the prevelent belief about the after life was that the heart of the decesed is balanced against a feather. If the heart is found to be lighter than a feather then the decesed is aloud to enter the Egyptian version of heaven and live out an eternity in joy.

We all know that a childs heart is at least as light as a feather and it can be assumed that this wise croc would know that too. So the mother simply has to say, "You will make my child very happy." The croc would then see that if he gives the child back to his mother, the child will be very happy. And if he eats the child, the childs heart will be weighed and found to be light and airy, as childrens hearts are want to be, and he will be placed in heaven where he will be very happy for all eternity. :P

Ah... this makes more sense. I like how you incorporated the cultural facts about ancient Egyptian beliefs and then created your conclusion based off of that. I had originally supposed this paradox to have no true answer because the 'right' answer was fully based on what the crocodile wanted. But I also agree with your idea as well. -_-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Mother: "If I say that you will eat the child, you will change your mind and say i'm wrong and eat the child. If I say that you will not eat the child, you will want to eat the child and say i'm wrong and eat the child."

Crocodile: "Aw, damit!" *eats child*

Edited by aaaa11112222

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Croc: Now guess what I will do with the child mwahahahahh@!!!!

Mom: You'll do *something.*

Croc: Noooooooo!!! (gives back child)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

The mother says to the Croc, "You're going to eat my child." The Croc would have to eat her child to make that true, but Croc said it would eat the child only if the mother's guess was incorrect, which means in order to falsify the mother's guess, the Croc would have to do anything except eat the child. That would make the Croc a liar. I believe the Croc would then be inclined to give the child back to the mother, as a reward for solving the riddle.

I read a similar riddle about a man, sentenced to die, who was told by the king he would be hanged for making a true statement, beheaded for making a false statement. The man told the king that he would be beheaded. By the same logic as the Croc and the mother, the man was set free.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
I would think that the only way to make ANY sense of the situation is for the woman to repeat back to the croc EXACTLY what he said to HER: "If I guess right, you'll give my baby back, if I dont, you'll eat him. That's what you'll do to him." He'd have to return the baby, because she's CORRECT NO MATTER WHAT. Eh? hehehe

J man's got it right, I think. Clever! :thumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Crocodile Sophism - Back to the Paradoxes

A slim crocodile living in Nile took a child. Mother begged to give him back. The crocodile could not only talk, he was also a great sophist, and so he stated: "If you guess (Edited: predict the fate = guess correctly), what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him." What statement shall the mother make to save her child (what about a vicious circle ...)?

"If you don't give him back, you will eat him, and if you don't eat him, you will give him back." This covers the crocodile's entire condition. He might eat the child, but then he would have lied, because the mother said what he will do with the child - either eat him, unless he gives him back, or give him back, unless he eats him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Croc: Now guess what I will do with the child mwahahahahh@!!!!

Mom: You'll do *something.*

Croc: Noooooooo!!! (gives back child)

Mom: You will play Candyland together after I've pwned you.

Croc: This all I have on me! Please!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Mom: You will be physical with the child.

Croc: You didn't let me finish!

Mom: Is it OK if I pick him up later?

Croc: Come back! This is a multiple choice!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

well here's what i think will happen:

When the mother is trying to guess, a man walks by, that man is...Chuck Norris. She doesn't even need to ask him for help for he...is Chuck Norris and can therefor read minds. CN then gives the Croc a stare that could turn Medusa to stone and the baby is then returned.

so there :lol::P

but on a serious note, the mother could give a response that covers all possible outcomes. like saying that the croc will do...somthing...as mentioned above :P

an analyst's work can be so much fun :lol:

Edited by No1slight

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Chuck Norris: You will play Candyland together after I've pwned you.

Croc: This is all I have on me! Please!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

The Mother should simply say you are going to eat my child....If this was the crocodiles intentions then she predicted the childs fate and the croc has to give it back...if it wasn't the crocs intentions and the croc eats the baby then that was the babies fate and the croc can't eat the baby cuz the mom answered correctly and the croc has to give the baby back

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

but if the Croc gives it back, then wasn't the Mother wrong? And when the Mother is wrong, doesn't the Croc eat the child?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Crocodile Sophism - Back to the Paradoxes

A slim crocodile living in Nile took a child. Mother begged to give him back. The crocodile could not only talk, he was also a great sophist, and so he stated: "If you guess (Edited: predict the fate = guess correctly), what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him." What statement shall the mother make to save her child (what about a vicious circle ...)?

The mother should Guess that the crocodile would eat him......He said it at the end.....OBVIOUSLY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Crocodile Sophism - Back to the Paradoxes

A slim crocodile living in Nile took a child. Mother begged to give him back. The crocodile could not only talk, he was also a great sophist, and so he stated: "If you guess (Edited: predict the fate = guess correctly), what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him." What statement shall the mother make to save her child (what about a vicious circle ...)?

well she could say "you will eat him" which if true then he will hav to giv him back, but then it would be false, therefore he would be eaten.but then the statement would be true soit carries on like this in circles :ph34r:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Crocodile Sophism - Back to the Paradoxes

A slim crocodile living in Nile took a child. Mother begged to give him back. The crocodile could not only talk, he was also a great sophist, and so he stated: "If you guess (Edited: predict the fate = guess correctly), what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him." What statement shall the mother make to save her child (what about a vicious circle ...)?

She should not guess his fate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Crocodile Sophism - Back to the Paradoxes

A slim crocodile living in Nile took a child. Mother begged to give him back. The crocodile could not only talk, he was also a great sophist, and so he stated: "If you guess (Edited: predict the fate = guess correctly), what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him." What statement shall the mother make to save her child (what about a vicious circle ...)?

The mother should respond "You will do the oppisite of whatever i guess you will do."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Ur right, but she could also say.

I have your child! If you guess , what I will do with him, I will return him. However, if you don't guess his fate I'll eat him. that way if the croc eats her boy, she will eat the croc's boy!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

There are 4 ways to treat this occurrence, resulting in 3 different outcomes for the 2 different consequences: 1- You can tell the croc he will give the child back and if you are right, you get the child back. 2- you can tell the croc he will NOT give you the child back and if you are right he is free to either eat the child or give it back since 'a', your guess was right and 'b', you guessed the croc would not give the child back and subsequently eat it. 3- you can tell the croc he will give the child back and if you are wrong he can eat the child. 4- you can tell the croc he will not give the child back and if you are wrong, again, he is free to either eat the child or give it back since 'a', your guess was wrong and 'b', you guessed the croc would not give the child back and subsequently eat it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...