BMAD 64 Report post Posted April 5, 2013 Object: to prove that i < 0 ( that is, sqrt(-1) < 0 ) ( .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i )^3 = (-1)^3 which means that .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i = -1 So then 1 + sqrt(3)*i = -2 sqrt(3)*i = -1 i = -1/sqrt(3) Therefore i is a negative number. QED. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
0 dark_magician_92 4 Report post Posted April 5, 2013 Object: to prove that i < 0 ( that is, sqrt(-1) < 0 ) ( .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i )^3 = (-1)^3 which means that .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i = -1 So then 1 + sqrt(3)*i = -2 sqrt(3)*i = -1 i = -1/sqrt(3) Therefore i is a negative number. QED. when talking about complex number, there are 2 things, magnitude and arguement 0.5+sqrt(3/4)*i 's magnitude is equal to one and the arguement results in the further -ve sign. as aruement is pi/3 and arguement^3=3*arguement(a property whose name i have forgetton i.e. arguement^n=n*arguement)=pi. and 1*pi =-1 in complex. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
0 rbn491 0 Report post Posted April 5, 2013 Obvious error in the proof is the part "which means that .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i = -1".. Generally when x^3=y^3, you can never directly say x is always equal to y.. It only leads to the conclusion that (x^3-y^3)=0, which on factorisation leads to (x-y)*(x^2+xy+y^2)=0.. So any further solution after that particular statement is not accepted in algebra.. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Object: to prove that i < 0 ( that is, sqrt(-1) < 0 )
( .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i )^3 = (-1)^3
which means that .5 + sqrt(3/4)*i = -1
So then 1 + sqrt(3)*i = -2
sqrt(3)*i = -1
i = -1/sqrt(3)
Therefore i is a negative number. QED.
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites