Jump to content
BrainDen.com - Brain Teasers

Sholay Mafia


Guest
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 329
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hirk, I did not accuse anybody but Miki, I was simply listing possibilities and trying to eliminate them and hoping others would do the same so we can work together to find the baddies. At least I am trying to be productive. And I stand by my link of you and Miki, which clears you. I think it makes sense to clear Thalia and Zweefer too since they were so concerned about keeping a tie going to avoid lynching a goodie with no cause.

I made a mistake above in saying Cube/Anon could be with Yodell, they can not both be bad because Yodell was the one to point out the possible baddie self spy, a baddie would not point to another baddie like that. And the above eliminations (me for being trapped n1, Hirk, Zweefer, Thalia) leaves Flame, Yodell, Bong, Anon. Since Anon and Yodell are not both bad, that is just 2 possibilities. Yodell, Flame, Bong, or Anon, Flame, Bong. Bong and Flame both voted against Cube/Anon day 1 and Flame was even number 4 to do that. Baddies might vote one of their own as a 2nd vote, but 2 of them and one was 4th? I doubt it. That leaves Yodell, Flame, Bong. Do they make sense as baddies?

Let's run through their day. Flame votes hirk, Yodell joins. Hirk shows up. Yodell moves to Cube and gives the self spy theory. Bong joins. Miki joins and expounds. FB jumps on. Cube defends. I accuse baddies of bandwagon. Bong, Yodell, FB all move to separate targets (baddies like to split up after being together). FB breaks the tie with a vote on Miki, Miki counters with a vote on Hirk. By this time everyone is worried about lynching a goodie and it would be suspicious to break the tie and would possibly fail as goodies try to counter any attempts. It is also possible some baddies were unable to change votes at this time.

So them as baddies is consistant in my view and is based on eliminating myself, Hirk for not voting for Miki when had the chance, Thalia & Zweefer for efforts to maintain tie, and Cube/Anon for being incompatible with Yodell or Bong/Flame.

Any wholes in my theory? Any better theories?

It also explains why Hirk is so suspicious of Flame I think, maybe Hirk saw the 4th bandwagon on Cube as too suspicious to not pursue? And turns out to be right. I was off the mark to focus on Miki.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought the night ends at 11pm EDT, which was 54 minutes ago. Have the end times been pushed back an hour for the rest of the game?

edit-n/m :)

Edited by Nana7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Night 3

The ranks of villagers were going thin every passing day/night. It was no different today either. Moreover, today they had killed one of their own, their protector. Dacoits had almost nothing to fear now. They decided to bring down the last pillar, without firing a bullet.

It happened in an instant if you believe Aura. Kaalia had taken a fancy to Nana, while Sambha shifted his voyeur to Bong. This allowed Gabbar to quickly disintegrate Hirkala using his sword. No bullets were fired tonight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Z. flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

2. Anon26

3. Bong

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

5. Zweefer

6. Thalia

7. Nana7

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala- DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

X. yoDell

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shoot. I wonder why they even bothered with the spy tonight, there is nobody left for them to get info about. They should have spied Hirk to confirm his id if anything. Tsk tsk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Z. flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

2. Anon26

3. Bong

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

5. Zweefer

6. Thalia

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala- DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

X. yoDell

is everyone supposed to start out self voting? I can add my vote back in if this needs to be edited

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for self

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - voting for self

6. Thalia - voting for self

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for self

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

@nana corrected, thanks :)

Edited by KlueMaster
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm fine with 24 hours too.

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for self

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - voting for self

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for self

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for self

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - flamebirde

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for self

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

I am trusting thalia and nana as i know they are good...

i am cool with 24hrs.

EDIT: that being said I am playing in a charity kickball tournament tomorrow, so will not be able to check back here until late afternoon, early evening if i need to change my vote (although i don't think I will).

Edited by Zweefer
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for self

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - flamebirde

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for flamebirde

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - flamebirde

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

I vote for Flame, but WILL change... reasons will be obvious..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Look, there are three baddies among us 7..

4 are goodies, three baddies.

For my part, I can do nothing but repeat that I am a goodie, and much have already been said by Cube previously..

Now,

When 5 people vote for someone, there ought to be a baddy in it.

So,

Fb have many votes,

if he is a goody:

Baddy will lynch him with us. And we lose.

If he is a baddy:

The baddy will vote for him just now, then will put up an excuse like "So many people are voting, it is bound to be a baddy bandwagon", and change there votes, and may even ours..

So I voted for FB, coz, the first person to change his vote, and asking us to change, can be a possible baddy, helping fb.

but a big flaw here was that if Fb is a goodie, by the time I realise it, and I mention, it might be too late for us goodies to change our vote..

So What I believe is,

I have strong doubts on Bong and Yodell.

It is my very doubts on Yodell that is making me feel uneasy about FB (yodell voted for FB)

but it still can be that both are in the league.

Chances of Thalia, Yodell and Bong, and Fb too be a baddy BY JUST CONSIDERING APPLICABle LOGIC, is equal.

Thalia have been spied, which makes her unlikely.

A very good point was raised by Nana,

What is the use of baddy spying now? they almost no everyone..

And that is why I think Bong as a baddy, planned to spy themselves.

So I wanted to vote for Bong and Yodell, and then wait.

IF we sspread our vote, it wont help...

I am changing my vote to Yodell in next post.

I will check the thread again later this day. If votes remain divided, I will revert back to FB or most majority guy (just so there is no possible flashvote)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for Yodell

3. Bong - voting for self

5. Zweefer - flamebirde

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anon.. I'm not gonna change my vote.. although I'm still not entirely sure who the baddies are .. Nana might have played us from the very beginning (although unlikely as I've said before) ... as well as Thalia might have .. as well as .. actually : you .. N1 spy might have the same meaning as a ploy to get our eyes off of Cube (yourself)

But the fact that flame broke the tie d1 and then kept a low profile.. giving us practically nothing although both my vote and Hirk's have been on him this whole time, it's NOT looking good...

Bong could be his fellow baddie (and the odds on this are growing by the minute) but you or thalia have the same odds against you .. So it's either you or bong or thalia... or maybe even zweefer as he was under the radar this whole time ....any of you could be baddies as far as I'm concerned .. for the same reasons .... but I'd rather vote for a known baddie then a potential one...

so my vote stays on Flame!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hosts: KlueMaster and Auramyna

Players:

Z. flamebirde - voting for self

2. Anon26 - voting for Yodell

3. Bong - voting for flamebirde

5. Zweefer - flamebirde

6. Thalia - voting for flamebirde

7. Nana7- voting for flamebirde

X. yoDell - voting for flamebirde

1. MiKi - lynched and found to be Jailor

4. Akriti - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

8. darth nox - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

9. Hirkala - DEAD - Killed by Gabbar

Might as well hop on the bandwagon...not much my vote can do...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...