Jump to content
BrainDen.com - Brain Teasers
Sign in to follow this  
Guest

Minecraft Mafia

Recommended Posts

Do I think EDM is a goodie? No. Will we learn something if she is not killed? Yes--if she escapes lynch at this point, we will definitely learn something, since she's 2 votes ahead of anyone else. Araver, I remain suspicious of you, but I prefer to leave it with EDM 2 votes ahead, so it'll take both vote redirects to save her. With only 2 vote redirects and only 4 people not voting for EDM, including myself, that narrows the options for identifying Zombie Pigman and Character.

With her exactly 2 votes ahead, we'll be guaranteed to know if both act to save her, regardless of whether they'd otherwise be shown, which I'm not quite certain of. Therefore I'll intentionally leave my vote blank.

And Araver, I can guarantee EDM isn't Notch.

Did not see this when I posted. But what I said to darth nox still stands. You just claimed Notch (there is no other way to interpret the last line).

You are wrong a little in that proposed strategy. About identifying Character - we need not do that. Plus Character has no gaining info-knowledge and would not know much about EDM (unless EDM is Character, in which case why would Zombie Pigman rescue her?). I'm slightly confused.

Again, from Role Descriptions, from all the goodies, Slime is the only one who should abstain, if the other goodies provide enough vote pressure on someone. You leaving your vote blank helps no one IMHO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Did not see this when I posted. But what I said to darth nox still stands. You just claimed Notch (there is no other way to interpret the last line).

You are wrong a little in that proposed strategy. About identifying Character - we need not do that. Plus Character has no gaining info-knowledge and would not know much about EDM (unless EDM is Character, in which case why would Zombie Pigman rescue her?). I'm slightly confused.

Again, from Role Descriptions, from all the goodies, Slime is the only one who should abstain, if the other goodies provide enough vote pressure on someone. You leaving your vote blank helps no one IMHO.

I prefer to have all information. With a variety of possible moves, knowing who is good and who is bad ensures that I will not act contrary to my interests. Thus it does remain valuable to ID each role. I wouldn't want to accidentally kill a goodie or save a baddie, so I prefer to have my identifications as specific as possible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

well since everyone is giving up there roles ill just be blunt, im squid.... if need be i can prove it but i dont want to unessacarily give up peoples roles that want to stay secret

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Server Owner: Blablah

1) Vineetrika - voting for EDM

3) Slick - voting for araver

4) Araver - Voting for EDM

9) GMaster479 - voting for araver

10) maurice - Trapped: Cannot vote or post.

11) EDM - voting for Molly Mae

13) Marq - Voting for EDM

14) Shadow - Voting for EDM

15) darth nox - Voting for EDM

17) Molly Mae - voting for EDM

DEAD:

2) Peace - Dead: Banned and found to be Ghast

5) Hirkala - Dead: Solidified by Herobrine and found to be Lava

6) Framm - Dead: Respawned at a remote location and found to be Spider

7) Abhisk - Dead: Drowned in obsidian formed by Lava and found to be Herobrine

8) solman - Dead: Exploded by Creeper

12) curr3nt - Dead: Pushed off of a cliff by Pig

16) sayalzah - Dead: Burnt in Lava and found to be Skeleton

Did not see this when I posted. But what I said to darth nox still stands. You just claimed Notch (there is no other way to interpret the last line).

You are wrong a little in that proposed strategy. About identifying Character - we need not do that. Plus Character has no gaining info-knowledge and would not know much about EDM (unless EDM is Character, in which case why would Zombie Pigman rescue her?). I'm slightly confused.

Again, from Role Descriptions, from all the goodies, Slime is the only one who should abstain, if the other goodies provide enough vote pressure on someone. You leaving your vote blank helps no one IMHO.

Fair enough...Slime, might I suggest abstaining? Saving your votes would be helpful for later. Or, if you prefer not to out yourself, it is certainly safe to not weight your vote.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Chicken should not waste a spy on Araver. Nor should we trap/spy a suspected goodie. There are better targets.

EDIT: If chicken spies a player who becomes trapped in the same night, is the trapped player safe from the spy?

No.

Clarification needed:

If Skeleton (or Notch) redirects someone with no night action (e.g. Slime), is that shown in the night-post? Or considered successful?.

That's been fluctuating in my mind, so yes, day action redirects are in the night post. I guess...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's been fluctuating in my mind, so yes, day action redirects are in the night post. I guess...

Thanks. Hmm, that patches my loophole. Even with the "I guess... in the end.

But I'm not sure what the effect of a night redirect on a day action would look like, especially for Slime's role - in this case it's logical to assume that if he adds private vote(s) the day after he is redirected, the extra vote(s) go to the person he was redirected too. Weird effect, but consistent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Day 3:

There was no contest. EDM would be lynched. EDM was not good, nor was she bad. No one, in the midst of all the confusion, thought that EDM might be the one person who wanted to be lynched. Even Zombie Pigman joined in.

Server Owner: Blablah

1) Vineetrika +1

3) Slick

4) Araver +1

9) GMaster479

10) maurice

13) Marq +1

14) Shadow +1

15) darth nox +1

17) Molly Mae +1

DEAD:

2) Peace - Dead: Banned and found to be Ghast

5) Hirkala - Dead: Solidified by Herobrine and found to be Lava

6) Framm - Dead: Respawned at a remote location and found to be Spider

7) Abhisk - Dead: Drowned in obsidian formed by Lava and found to be Herobrine

8) solman - Dead: Exploded by Creeper

11) EDM - Dead: Picked up in a bucket and found to be Water

12) curr3nt - Dead: Pushed off of a cliff by Pig

16) sayalzah - Dead: Burnt in Lava and found to be Skeleton

Liquids (Hirk and EDM) Win!

The game continues until the next win, though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

araver, oh I need your help tonight. You will not regret it. Trust me. I fear Pig has the wrong idea.

Edit-punctuation

Edited by maurice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

GDI...

@Shad: I thought you were fishing for votes, so I had you down as Water. I should have figured it was EDM, since she never responded... Gdi..

Someone needs to kill Maurice.

@Nox: I was really hoping you'd catch what I was saying without everyone knowing...but okay. It's all the same.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

@MM how was I fishing for votes? I honestly don't know how I was doing that, and would like the experience to note for future games, so I can avoid it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Shad: Just the things you said and the way your vote changed.

@Nox: People you should not target:

3) Slick

4) Araver +1

9) GMaster479

13) Marq +1

14) Shadow +1

15) darth nox +1

17) Molly Mae +1

=P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What I see for now: Chicken should target one of our primary suspects (marq and maurice) and Squid should target one who already claimed something and was not backed up yet (me, shadow, darthnox). And if Notch gets a save, save yourself, otherwise refrain from interfering. Only goodies and night-kill exist tonight (Creeper is passive and Zombie is worthless with so much outing going on). Pig, whatever you wish. Don't waste it on me though, I'm betting the baddies will do that.

Anyone has anything better? If not, then I'll go back to my shell and wait for tomorrow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

araver, oh I need your help tonight. You will not regret it. Trust me. I fear Pig has the wrong idea.

Edit-punctuation

Nice try, but no. You can defend with words.

And Pig can do whatever he damn pleases. He does that anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

@Shad: Just the things you said and the way your vote changed.

@Nox: People you should not target:

3) Slick

4) Araver +1

9) GMaster479

10) maurice

13) Marq +1

14) Shadow +1

15) darth nox +1

17) Molly Mae +1

=P

:thumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey, Mo... can you tell us who's hiding among us? =P

@Araver: I figure Mo's the highest probability of a baddie. I'd like to spread our spies over two targets that I don't have roles for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Nice try, but no. You can defend with words.

And Pig can do whatever he damn pleases. He does that anyway.

araver gets feisty (and frankly kinda mean :unsure: ) when his hair gets too long.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, I will apologize for that. Again, for me does not sound mean. Just accurate. But I could have expressed it better.

@Molly - Spreading spies. Well that can be arranged ... we have a role that can almost spy. shoot first, ask questions later. Now for the other spy.

EDIT: Confused usernames.

Edited by araver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

By the way, tonight will get a... special post, so expect it a bit late. Oddly, the actions fit in quite well with a something I've wanted to do for a while.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh, joy. Blahblah's at it again.

@curr3nt: I know you're dead, but you were right. We should have killed him...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

By the way, tonight will get a... special post, so expect it a bit late. Oddly, the actions fit in quite well with a something I've wanted to do for a while.

Ooh, goodie!!

popcorn.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...