Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

Princess Bride Mafia

404 posts in this topic

Posted · Report post

Well, I think I get your hint, but I don't see how voting for you will help any.

What would you do instead?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

What would you do instead?

I was hoping someone who had discovered some information last night would get a vote going (ie. Valerie or the Narrator), but maybe they spied on the wrong people. Itachi's voting for Mekal, maybe he knows something. I not really sure what Y-san is trying to accomplish. :huh:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane

Prof. Templeton

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

There's no real reason that I'm voting for Mekal, just want to see what he has to say :P Plus, I'm hoping that a goodie with more info will vote for someone he/she knows is a baddie, and so far, the only two voted people are Y-san and Mekal. Y-san is just making me very, very :wacko: and I have no clue what role she has. I believe Mekal hasn't said anything since Itachi voted for him, so that gets me a bit <_< My current vote is completely guess, so I'm most likely going to change it if someone else looks more suspicious. Just wanted to get my vote in 'cause I probably don't have time later :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I need a vote from everyone before the day's over or you get counted as inactive and replaced. 6 more hours from the time of this post! :ph34r:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Oh...I have my reasons (although I was hoping no one would come out and explain like CL did...oh well...)...I'll explain later in the day...hehe ;P

Forgot dms's vote...

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane

Prof. Templeton

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

And Prof. T, I'm not sure if it's b/c you haven't played many mafia games (or b/c of another more sinister reason which I will explain later :P), but if Itachi is smart and experienced enough that if he were Valerie he wouldn't get himself killed with the random immediate vote for a baddie...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

O.K. I guess i didn't get your hint before (I thought that phear guy was it), but I understand now. So I'll go along for now.

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Sorry, Y-san, I thought it was obvious.

And Prof. T, I'm not sure if it's b/c you haven't played many mafia games (or b/c of another more sinister reason which I will explain later :P), but if Itachi is smart and experienced enough that if he were Valerie he wouldn't get himself killed with the random immediate vote for a baddie...

I can think of two explanations for Itachi-s vote. One makes him a baddie, the other a clever innocent. But without the voting discussion, I don't know which.

Since PG is fussing about votes, I'll go ahead and post mine:

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

(I thought that phear guy was it), but I understand now. So I'll go along for now.

huh?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Sorry, Y-san, I thought it was obvious.

I can think of two explanations for Itachi-s vote. One makes him a baddie, the other a clever innocent. But without the voting discussion, I don't know which.

Since PG is fussing about votes, I'll go ahead and post mine:

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Mekal

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

I am voting for mekal because I htink he is a baddie.

If Ysan is not a baddie then I dont get why we would vote for her. Unless she is a very good character that cant die by a lynch.

But then we would be wasting a lynch kill on a good player when we could be going after a baddie player.

So does Ysan want us to waste a vote = she is a baddie?

And if Itachi is who I think he is...I agree that he may have gotten himself targeted for a kill tonight.

Or he could be planning on us thinking that...he is a really good player...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

huh?

:ph34r: kinda looks like wesley with his mask on, no?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

:ph34r: kinda looks like wesley with his mask on, no?

hahah! nice, I didn't think of it like that!

Edit: also, too many inactives... maybe the Y-San thing killed discussion, but that's no excuse for not participating at all. Come on people!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

If Ysan is not a baddie then I dont get why we would vote for her. Unless she is a very good character that cant die by a lynch.

But then we would be wasting a lynch kill on a good player when we could be going after a baddie player.

So does Ysan want us to waste a vote = she is a baddie?

I don't think Y-san would want us to lynch her if she really ends up being a baddie... wouldn't it be better for us goodies to accuse a goodie whether than definitely getting a baddie? Or maybe she's using opposite phsychology (making herself seem suspicious hoping others would dismiss it and think she's innocent)... <_< Atm, I have no clue what Y-san is doing :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb - voting for Mekal

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Mekal

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

just b/c I want to learn something today and not allow it to be a total waste.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Sorry, Y-san, I thought it was obvious.

I can think of two explanations for Itachi-s vote. One makes him a baddie, the other a clever innocent. But without the voting discussion, I don't know which.

Since PG is fussing about votes, I'll go ahead and post mine:

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

Actually, I was talking about Prof. T's assertion about Itachi voting for Mekal b/c he is Valerie...;P

And I'm glad you got it...but you forgot one thing ;)...I'll explain the rest later though...

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Mekal

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

I am voting for mekal because I htink he is a baddie.

If Ysan is not a baddie then I dont get why we would vote for her. Unless she is a very good character that cant die by a lynch.

But then we would be wasting a lynch kill on a good player when we could be going after a baddie player.

So does Ysan want us to waste a vote = she is a baddie?

And if Itachi is who I think he is...I agree that he may have gotten himself targeted for a kill tonight.

Or he could be planning on us thinking that...he is a really good player...

Then why aren't you voting for me then?

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb - voting for Mekal

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Mekal

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

just b/c I want to learn something today and not allow it to be a total waste.

Oh, Bb...but I've learned plenty...I have two very good suspects right now...and 2 kinda suspects...well, make that 3...hehe ;P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I am getting a bit annoyed at the inactives. We cant really play unless we all take part.

Slick where are you? I remember you state that you could play as much but this is

unusual for you to be gone so much.

Woon? Whats up bud? Or are you hiding from me because you killed my man?

Plus, if you all dont post I cant figure out who the baddies are!

Now, I dont really think that mekal is bad cause why would Vizzini go after him if

he was good? But Ysan has me totally confused. If she is Fezzik she cant be lynched but will be out of

commission for a day and night. If this is right then I would rather lynch her and not loose

Mekal who could be a goodie.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Akaslickster

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb - voting for Mekal

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Yoruichi-san

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

Im voting for ysan because I think she wont die in the lynch and I dont want to kill

an innocent/goodie..as I think mekal might be.

edit: remove quote tag

Edited by crazypainter
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster-voting for Mekal

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb - voting for Mekal

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Yoruichi-san

Woon

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

I had someone else in mind but, too late now, it is one or the other. :( EDIT CP change to Y-san. I worked today. :P

Edited by akaslickster
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Host: S. Morgenstern

Akaslickster-voting for Mekal

Itachi-san - voting for Mekal

Prince_Marth85 – dead (killed by Roberts)

Brandonb - voting for Mekal

Frozen_in_Fire

CrazyPainter voting for Yoruichi-san

Woon - voting for Yoruichi-san

Mekal

Cherry Lane - voting for Yoruichi-san

Prof. Templeton - voting for Yoruichi-san

Yoruichi-san - voting for Yoruichi-san

Dms172 - voting for Yoruichi-san

Star_Tiger - voting for Mekal

I still try to figure what Y-san trying to do but as for now, I will fulfill your wish to see what will happen. <_<

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

At the risk of being added to Y-san's suspect list (if I'm not there already), I'm thinking about switching my vote to Mekal for the same reason Brandonb said. Also we haven't heard from Mekal at all today. What's up Bud? Maybe it's better to go out on a limb then to lynch someone and not learn anything before the next night. Y-san seems to have a plan in mind, but I can't see it just yet. I'm torn.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

At the risk of being added to Y-san's suspect list (if I'm not there already), I'm thinking about switching my vote to Mekal for the same reason Brandonb said. Also we haven't heard from Mekal at all today. What's up Bud? Maybe it's better to go out on a limb then to lynch someone and not learn anything before the next night. Y-san seems to have a plan in mind, but I can't see it just yet. I'm torn.

I see it. I see it all :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

At the risk of being added to Y-san's suspect list (if I'm not there already), I'm thinking about switching my vote to Mekal for the same reason Brandonb said. Also we haven't heard from Mekal at all today. What's up Bud? Maybe it's better to go out on a limb then to lynch someone and not learn anything before the next night. Y-san seems to have a plan in mind, but I can't see it just yet. I'm torn.

I disagree. I'm pretty sure Mekal's innocent. But even if I wasn't, I don't like the idea of a random lynch where we potentially lose an innocent over a non-lynch.

What do we have against Mekal, anyway. Itachi made a random comment about a white horse. That's it. So unless someone has some evidence, the choice of Mekal looks random...or worse.

Itachi, if you continue with your vote for Mekal without any indication of why, I'll have to consider you a baddie. The others are mostly bandwagon votes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Actually after further review(I really ought to take notes for these things) I think i know why Itachi would vote for Mekal. So I'll stick with Y-san's plan.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I disagree. I'm pretty sure Mekal's innocent. But even if I wasn't, I don't like the idea of a random lynch where we potentially lose an innocent over a non-lynch.

What do we have against Mekal, anyway. Itachi made a random comment about a white horse. That's it. So unless someone has some evidence, the choice of Mekal looks random...or worse.

Itachi, if you continue with your vote for Mekal without any indication of why, I'll have to consider you a baddie. The others are mostly bandwagon votes.

Cl, about itachi's white horse comment I think he is refering to the last night post when valerie is looking out the window.

Do you mean that itachi could be a baddie? I dont see it but I will look closer...

As for now I am sticking with my vote for ysan cause I dont think it will hurt us and I htink killing mekal will.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I disagree. I'm pretty sure Mekal's innocent. But even if I wasn't, I don't like the idea of a random lynch where we potentially lose an innocent over a non-lynch.

What do we have against Mekal, anyway. Itachi made a random comment about a white horse. That's it. So unless someone has some evidence, the choice of Mekal looks random...or worse.

Itachi, if you continue with your vote for Mekal without any indication of why, I'll have to consider you a baddie. The others are mostly bandwagon votes.

I agree with CL. I think she sees the same thing I do now. But innocents, thinking about it: from the probabilities and from past experience, it is much more likely that the random bandwagon on Day 1 is for an innocent. So your choices are either to lynch me knowing it won't hurt the innocents any (and will buy me protection ;)) or to lynch someone who has a much higher probability of being an innocent than a baddie, especially since we know he can't be Vizzini...(actually that brings up another one of my points which I will explain in the next post)

Anyways, my experience with randomly lynching someone just for inactivity (especially as it looks to me that Mekal just hasn't been on BD at all) has been bad...but I will explain everything fully soon.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

So I guess this means that we don't get to put any type of squeeze on Mekal. Blah, I guess we can call it a day then if everyone is not going to change their votes. And if someone does, then just count my vote towards Ysan since it's too late to hear from Mekal now anyway <_<

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.