[rookie1ja]

Fraction - Back to the Number Puzzles
Can you arrange 9 numerals - 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 - (using each numeral just once) above and below a division line, to create a fraction equaling to 1/3 (one third)?

Spoiler for Solution:

Fraction - solution
5832/17496 = 1/3

[sn00bino]

I understand the solution. But how do you find it ? You can ' t test everything.
Sorry for my poor english

[rookie1ja]

Quote

I understand the solution. But how do you find it ? You can ' t test everything.
Sorry for my poor english

A few hints:
1. first number must have 4 digits
2. second number must have 5 digits
3. second number must start with either 1 or 2
4. first number can not start with either 1 or 2

[sn00bino]

Why must the second number start with 1 or 2 ?

[rookie1ja]

Quote

Why must the second number start with 1 or 2 ?

Because if you multiply a 4-digit number by 3, you can not get a number which is 30000 or bigger.

[sn00bino]

ok thank you

[lovruch]

numerator is 4 digit, denominator is 5 digit, 5 must be in numerator and only feasible place is the thousands place, hence denominator must start with 16 or 17,
denominator can't be 16*** because the ratio has to be 1/3 and only choices for hundreds place in numerator that are 4 and 6 will violate this condition or cause repetition, hence the number is 5***/17***, now hundreds place in num can be occupied only by 8 or 9, it can't be 9 or there will be repetition, so number is 58**/17***, now just simple hit and try on the ones and tens place of numerator will result in 5832/17496

[fsm]

5823/17469 also works

[robxmccarthy]

This one just about made my head explode. I took the same logical work down approach, but I couldn't get the last few numbers. I kept getting one repetition.

[strikefiend]

Wow, thanks for the answer. I'd been trying to use 1-9 on the top AND bottom of the problem until i gave in and had a look at the solution. Could someone check for me and see if all nine on the top AND bottom is even able to be accomplished. As far as I can tell, it's not.