oops! thought I was a captioner... but I see now I'm not.... I still want to play but we need someone to do a caption after me right?
Oh Well... I'll remove my name If we need me to.(I was late anyway)
I agree with wafflechip and if they are faceing each other why can't they see the others hat and the feathers in it?(unless they have their eyes shut, which wasn't stated in the OP) Are you sure you have stated the puzzle correctly?