235 replies to this topic

[benjer3]

BrainIAC: Y-san
Roster:
1) Hirkala - DEAD [?] Killed by Hawkgirl
2) marquessa - DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
3) curr3nt - DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
4) Molly Mae
5) Yodell
6) TheChad - DEAD [Sinestro] Lynched
7) Panther - voting for Molly Mae
8) Framm
9) MikeD - voting for Molly Mae
10) nana77- voting for Molly Mae
11) TwoaDay - voting for Molly Mae
12) jay
13) Flamebirde DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
14) Aura
15) benjer3 - voting for Molly Mae

I guess we're going after Molly.

[Framm 18]

BrainIAC: Y-san
Roster:
1) Hirkala - DEAD [?] Killed by Hawkgirl
2) marquessa - DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
3) curr3nt - DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
4) Molly Mae
5) Yodell
6) TheChad - DEAD [Sinestro] Lynched
7) Panther - voting for Molly Mae
8) Framm - voting for Molly Mae
9) MikeD - voting for Molly Mae
10) nana77- voting for Molly Mae
11) TwoaDay - voting for Molly Mae
12) jay
13) Flamebirde DEAD [?] Killed by Villains
14) Aura
15) benjer3 - voting for Molly Mae

[TwoaDay]

yeah y-san sent it on the 13th at like 11:30 pm, i didnt see it untill today at like 11:30 am lol, and ok so yeah, sry, hirk didnt have to be indy


edit: spelling

Edited by TwoaDay, 15 August 2012 - 11:23 PM.

[nana77]

One problem with the Hirk was baddie theory is TheChad put the nail in his coffin d1 rather than try to get votes onto Jay or Twoaday.

For that matter, not voting at all would have allowed the Joker to make a tie which results in no deaths, thus saving their lynch save for another day.

Though players do not always play optimum, and voting for Hirk and then using the lynch save could have been done for cover I suppose.

[nana77]

yeah y-san sent it on the 13th at like 11:30 pm, i didnt see it untill today at like 11:30 am lol, and ok so yeah, sry, hirk didnt have to be indy


edit: spelling

So it is not today's day action. oops

Edited by nana77, 15 August 2012 - 11:36 PM.

[Yoruichi-san]

If you can find me one ;P

[Aura12]

Why is BD so wonky at the moment?
I guess you've all worked it out but MikeD is my "definite goodie".
@mikeD - I'll check the logic later when I get home but I guess we're good for today. *woohoo*
If you inspect the "code" you'll see neither my name or role is included as I'd already IDed myself.

I vote MollyMae

Edited by Aura12, 16 August 2012 - 03:01 AM.

[Yodell]

I vote MollyMae as well...but that leaves us with one big question: who's the last baddie....
There were 4: one down, leaves 3.... Ok, lets say HG got one N2... That would make jay the last one...
But... All baddies acted so far.. And jay was inactive...
Q to Ysan: can baddies power play each other??

[Yodell]

And no. I'm not a baddie voting just because there's no chance for MM.... I also voted for TheChad ... Among the first ones....

[Yodell]

One problem with the Hirk was baddie theory is TheChad put the nail in his coffin d1 rather than try to get votes onto Jay or Twoaday. For that matter, not voting at all would have allowed the Joker to make a tie which results in no deaths, thus saving their lynch save for another day. Though players do not always play optimum, and voting for Hirk and then using the lynch save could have been done for cover I suppose.

Not necessarily .. Joker has to choose the target that he steal the vote from during the night : " Each Night, he may dose one player with his laughing gas and steal their vote the following Day (i.e. his vote becomes X2 and theirs X0; if the player dies that Night, he cannot gain)"



on anther note:

curr3nt made it preatty clear who he was... unfortunatelly he redirected lex to himself last night .. (saving aura or nana I think .. or maybe mike - but I think he saved aura) so it's not like Panther described it....

Since the baddies offed Current, presumably seeing him as a threat, we can probably assume that he was right with at least two of the names that he suggested as baddies, as if he was completely wrong and leading us down the wrong trail, then the baddies would want to encourage that, not kill him off. For reference, Current's list of suspects consisted of Molly, MikeD, Jay and myself. By this reasoning, I suggest we vote for one of those people. I am more inclined to vote for either Molly or Jay rather than MikeD, as those two have said the least of the three. So, using this logic, I tossed a coin to decide between the two and it came up with Molly

I'm not saying Panther is a baddie... but.. he might be misled by the fact that curr3nt was killed by Lex...