It's going to be extremely obvious almost as soon as conversation begins progressing because it's so much better if you are listening to it instead of typing, but hey.
Also, it's a kind of progressive puzzle. So every time I post an answer, I'm going to post a new 'puzzle'. This may sound confusing, but it'll get really simple as we go through it.
I have the ball. I give the ball to MissKitten, who throws it to MollyMae. MollyMae tosses the ball to Rookie1ja. Who has the ball?
Edited by Brainiac100, 30 May 2012 - 09:02 PM.