What other claim can a baddie make? Is the only winning strat supposed to be that the baddies are never spied or questioned for lynching?
Just guessing by an earlier comment that you gave the vanillas "flavors". Doesn't that instantly out any baddie trying to avoid suspicion? And even more, out the godfather who would appear as a vanilla but not know the secret that all the other vanilla know?
Well I wasn't going to post, but as you have already...
I am interested in seeing what vanillas knew plus secret ability. From an outsider's perspective the baddies had no chance and in fact were an informed minority playing against an uninformed minority- informed majority combination...oh yeah puzzles...but from what I saw it appears the informed majority had an easy puzzle to solve.
Also, stating the balance was in the secret ability...well baddies only had a 2/9 chance to solve it...maybe a little more if you assume they had BTSC already and could work together. But even that's not a safe assumption to make.
Anyway, I still hate Vanilla roles. I think colouring them with flavours only made me hate them even more. Also seems they had a secret ability, either explicit or implicit, that was not announced in the OP.
Edited by maurice, 19 September 2011 - 02:55 PM.